2. Results and Discussion
As shown in
Figure 1, with addition of a polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP) modifier, the shape of Cu
2O was successfully altered from cube to cuboctahedron and octahedron due to the preferential absorption to the {111} planes of the Cu
2O crystals [
15]. Samples are denoted as c, co and o. The exposed surfaces of cube, cuboctahedron and octahedron were composed of six {100} facets, eight {111} facets and six {100} facets, and eight {111} facets, respectively. The size of particles was in the range of 600–800 nm. The PVP with higher molecular weight was more beneficial for the shape transformation from octahedron to cuboctahedron. PVP is a non-ionic surfactant, and an easily polarized functional group—C=O is included in its repetition unit. For a polymer, the length of the molecular chain is proportional to its molecular weight. With higher molecular weight of PVP, the absorption dots to Cu
2O particles would decrease due to the space restriction, which would in turn decrease the ratio of {111}/{100} [
15,
16,
17]. As shown in
Figure 1, when the molecular weight of PVP increased from 29,000 to 40,000, the shape of Cu
2O changed from octahedron to cuboctahedron.
The co-catalytic activity of the deposits highly depends on its particle size. Generally speaking, deposits with smaller particle size show higher specific surface area, and high photocatalytic activity can be expected. The prepared Cu2O with such a large particle size (600–800 nm) might not be good for its catalytic activity, thus Cu2O with much smaller particle size was synthesized at room temperature, denoted as r-c, r-co and r-o. Although it was a little challenging to obtain very high resolution images with clear edges, due to the small size of particles and resolution limitation of the SEM equipment, morphology evolution of faceted Cu2O particles (FCPs) could still be observed from cube (only {100} facets) to cuboctahedron (coexist of {100} and {111} facets) and octahedron (only {111} facets), with preferential absorption of PVP modifier to the {111} planes of the Cu2O crystals. High reaction temperature was beneficial for the fast growth of the particles, thus particles with bigger size were formed at 328 K. On the contrary, when reaction of Cu2O occurred at room temperature, FCPs with much smaller size (70–130 nm) could be synthesized as shown in the inserted size distribution histograms.
As expected, no peaks of CuO or Cu were detected in the XRD patterns in
Figure 2. Only peaks attributed to Cu
2O were observed. This indicates the successful synthesis of Cu
2O without other crystalline contaminants. Peaks located at 29.6°, 36.5°, 42.4° and 52.5° are attributed to the {110}, {111}, {200} and {211} facets of Cu
2O, respectively.
As shown in
Figure 3, cuboctahedron Cu
2O showed the highest CO
2 evolution rate, followed by octahedron and cube. Some researchers found that the {111} facet is more photocatalytically active than the {100} facet, due to the fact that the surface energy of the {100} facet was lower than that of the {111} facet. Thus, it is expected that cubic Cu
2O with six exposed {100} facets had lower photocatalytic activity than octahedron Cu
2O with eight exposed {111} facets. In cuboctahedron Cu
2O, eight {111} facets and six {100} facets are exposed. A possible explanation is that the energy difference in the {100} and {111} facets allows better charge separation and transfer, thus electron-hole recombination can be suppressed. Therefore, a higher photocatalytic activity is obtained for the cuboctahedron compared to the cube and octahedron. It is worthwhile to note that the photoactivity of Cu
2O nanoparticles was much lower than that of ST-G2 (mainly rutile titania). The reason might be that Cu
2O could react with acetic acid into copper(II) ions, which could reduce its photocatalytic activity. This is evidenced by the color change of the reaction solution which ended up with a slightly blueish color after the photocatalytic activity measurement. Thus, co-catalytic activity of FCP-loaded ST-G2 is discussed in the following section.
FCP-loaded titania was prepared by in-situ wet chemical method at room temperature, denoted as r-c-S, r-co-S and r-o-S. The theoretical loading amount of faceted Cu
2O particles was 2 wt%. Faceted Cu
2O particles with shapes of cube, cuboctahedron and octahedron can be observed in SEM images in
Figure 4. The shape evolution of faceted Cu
2O particles can be better observed for FCP-loaded titania synthesized at 328 K (See
Figure S1). The density of FCPs is low, due to the low loading amount of faceted Cu
2O particles. Other particles are attributed to ST-G2 titania particles. It seemed that faceted Cu
2O particles were well-interacted with titania particles due to the in-situ wet chemical method. Elemental mapping and EDS analyses were also performed for titania and FCP-loaded titania (See
Figures S2 and S3). EDS results showed that no peaks of copper element were detected on bare ST-G2 powder. On the other hand, a peak with energy of 0.930 keV was observed for all FCP-loaded ST-G2 composites (c-S, co-S and o-S). This implies that Cu
2O was successfully loaded onto ST-G2 particles by the wet chemical synthesis, which is in good agreement with XRD patterns.
Figure 5 shows that no peaks of CuO, Cu or other contaminants were detected in the XRD patterns. Peaks located at 27.7°, 36.3° and 54.8° in
Figure 5b are assigned to the {110}, {101} and {211} planes of rutile titania, respectively. Peaks at 25.4° and 48.16° are the characteristic peaks for anatase titania with planes of {101} and {200}, respectively. The XRD results confirmed the composition of ST-G2, including approximately 97% of rutile and 3% anatase titania; ST-G2 is mainly composed of the rutile phase with small amount of anatase. The particle size of ST-G2 is large, approximately 500 nm. In terms of in-situ synthesized FCP-loaded titania composites,
Figure 5a shows that new peaks located at 36.5° and 42.4° were observed, which are attributed to the {111} and {200} planes of Cu
2O. This was also in good agreement with XRD patterns of FCP-loaded titania synthesized at 328 K (See
Figure S4). This implies the successful loading of FCP deposits onto ST-G2 by wet chemical synthesis.
Figure 6 shows that ST-G2 titania (mainly rutile) can absorb light with wavelengths longer than 420 nm, due to its large bandgap. The loading of FCPs could extend the light absorption of ST-G2 to the visible-light range. Thus, the FCP-loaded titania showed much higher absorption than that of bare titania. It is consistent with the results of FCP-loaded titania synthesized at 328 K (See
Figure S5). As it has been reported that titania is one of the most promising photocatalysts due to its high chemical stability, sufficient energy to drive various photocatalytic reactions and inexpensiveness, despite that only ultraviolet light can be absorbed due to its large bandgap (3.0–3.2 eV). The deposition of FCPs on titania can be a promising and facile method to extend the light absorption of titania to utilize visible light in the whole light spectrum.
The Kubelka–Munk function derived from reflection spectra shows that the calculated bandgap of ST-G2 was 3.05 eV, which is comparable to the reported value of 3.0 eV. In terms of the FCP-loaded ST-G2, two components could be seen in the Tauc plot in
Figure 6b. The calculated bandgap of Cu
2O was 2.0 eV, which agrees well with reported bandgap of 2.0–2.2 eV [
18,
19]. Taking into account of SEM, XRD and diffuse reflectance spectroscopy (DRS), it can be concluded that FCP-loaded ST-G2 was successfully synthesized by the wet chemical method, and the synthesized composites may be visible light-active photocatalysts.
In order to understand the co-catalytic action of FCP deposits on titania, photocatalytic activity of titania (ST-G2) and FCP-loaded titania was examined in a CO
2 system.
Figure 7a shows that FCP-loaded titania showed much higher photocatalytic activity than that of bare titania, suggesting the role of FCPs as an electron sink, which helps accumulation of electrons to drive oxygen reduction reactions. The photocatalytic activity of FCP-loaded titania decreased in the sequence of cube > cuboctahedron > octahedron, due to the preferable electron transfer from titania to {100} facets rather than {111} facets of FCPs. It is worthwhile to note that the r-c-S showed photocatalytic activity seven times as high as the that of bare ST-G2, implying the role of FCPs in suppressing electron-hole recombination and accelerating electrons diffusion from titania to FCPs due to the difference of electron concentration under UV-light illumination.
Compared to the photocatalytic activity of physically blended Cu
2O-loaded titania (b-S), much enhanced photocatalytic activity was observed for the sample r-c-S. This indicates that good interaction between Cu
2O and titania was achieved by the in-situ wet chemical synthesis, which may lead to fast electron transfer between particles [
20]. In addition, it is interesting to find that the r-c-S sample also showed higher photocatalytic activity than that of (noble metal) Pt-loaded titania. This can be explained by several aspects: (1) The Cu
2O particles serve as an electron sink to accumulate photogenerated electrons from titania, which can be consumed to drive the oxygen reduction reaction. (2) The {100} facet of Cu
2O particles is the most active facet to favourably accumulate electrons transferred from titania. (3) Cu
2O has a higher ability of molecular-oxygen adsorption, which allows quick consumption of accumulated electrons and suppression of electron-hole recombination. (4) The possible multielectron oxygen reduction occurs as the counter reaction of the photodecomposition of organic compounds.
As shown in
Figure 8a, since the CBB of anatase titania has been reported to be 0.20V more negative than the standard electrode potential of one-electron oxygen reduction, one-electron oxygen reduction takes place. On the other hand, the CBB of rutile titania is a little more positive than the one-electron oxygen reduction potential, thus two-electron reduction of oxygen occurs [
21]. Therefore, it is considered that two-electron reduction of oxygen may occur in rutile titania and one-electron reduction of oxygen in anatase titania. A sample ST-G2 (Showa Denko Ceramics) is composed of mainly rutile and a small portion of anatase, while the other sample FP6 (Showa Denko Ceramics) is composed of mainly anatase and a small portion of rutile. The photocatalytic activity of ST-G2 was much lower than that of FP6, due to the lower CBB position to drive one-electron reduction of oxygen and absence of surface/bulk sites to accumulate excited electrons to drive multielectron oxygen reduction reactions.
The oxygen reduction reaction kinetics of bare titania (ST-G2) and FCP-loaded titania (r-c-S) in photodecomposition of organic compounds were investigated by the light-intensity dependence (LID) measurement under UV-LED (365 nm) irradiation, on the assumption that (i) only the titania particles with accumulated two electrons can reduce oxygen without deactivation. In this scheme, if the one-electron bearing particles cannot absorb the second photon, they are deactivated leading to no chemical reactions. (ii) Organics decomposition proceeds through peroxy radical-mediated radical chain reaction. Since the CBB of rutile titania is slightly more positive than the standard electrode potential of one-electron reduction of oxygen, multielectron (two or four) oxygen reduction (MOR) might occur [
22,
23,
24,
25].
Then, a kinetic model was used to analyze LID. The following reaction steps involving titania (<TiO
2>), one electron-bearing titania (<TiO
2(e
−)>), two electron-bearing titania (<TiO
2(e
−e
−)>), reaction substrate (RH), peroxy radical chain carrier (RO
2·), hydroperoxide (RO
2H) and its dimer (RO
4R), are assumed.
where
I,
ψ0,
ψ1,
φ and
k’s are light intensity, absorption efficiency of <TiO
2>, absorption efficiency of <TiO
2(e
−)>, quantum efficiency of charge separation and rate constants, respectively. In this model, oxidation of RH starts only by <TiO
2(e
−e
−)>, i.e., two-photon absorption is necessary as is autooxidation, a radical-chain reaction by the RO
2· chain carrier. The efficiency of excitation to create an electron-positive hole pair,
φ, can be assumed to be the same for < TiO
2> and < TiO
2(e
−)>, since the efficiency depends predominantly on the properties of titania, while photoabsorption coefficients,
ψ0 and
ψ1, may be different, since
ψ0 depends predominantly on the bulk composition, i.e., the photoabsorption coefficient of titania, but
ψ1 must depend also on the effective size of a particle, as discussed later.
By applying steady-state approximation to <TiO
2(e
−)>, <TiO
2(e
−e
−)>, R· and RO
2· (d[TiO
2(e
−)]/dt = d[TiO
2(e
−e
−)]/dt = d[R·]/dt = d[RO
2·]/dt = 0), the following equations are derived.
Concentrations of <TiO
2(e
−)>, <TiO
2(e
−e
−)> and RO
2· are obtained from Equations (9) and (10) as:
Then, overall rate (
r) is obtained as,
where
a =
1/{
τ1(1 + 1/
k[RH]
τ2)}
. Assuming sufficiently high chain length of the second-term radical chain to be able to neglect the first term in Equation (17), the LID of rate
r can be of the first and 0.5th-order at the low and high limit of light intensity,
I [
17]. At the low and high limit of light intensity,
I, the rates are:
where,
b and
c correspond to
kp[RH] (
aψ0ψ1φ2/
kt)
1/2 and (1/
ψ1φτ1)
1/2, respectively. The presumed bimodal LID was observed for bare ST-G2 (
Figure 8). The first-order dependence is interpreted by the fact that, at lower light intensity, the probability of accumulation of two electrons, i.e., absorption of two photons in a photocatalyst particle, is low and LID of this event should be second order to lead to first order LID of the overall rate by multiplication of 0.5th-order LID of the following radical chain reaction. At the higher light intensity, the probability of two-photon absorption is sufficiently high to make the LID of two-electron accumulation first order to result in 0.5th order overall-rate LID.
By loading FCPs on ST-G2, the activity was much enhanced, i.e., LID was shifted upward as shown in
Figure 8. The inflection point of the first and 0.5th-order LID observed at ca. 2.5 (ln
I) and the first-order LID could not be seen when r-c-S was used as a photocatalyst. Since
r(low) =
r(high) at the inflection point,
Ithr,
Ithr is calculated to be 1/
ψ1φτ1. Photoabsorption efficiency of <TiO
2(e
−)>,
ψ1, depends on the size of particles; the larger the size is, the higher becomes the probability of absorbing a second photon to be <TiO
2(e
−e
−)>, and therefore it is assumed that
ψ1 is constant for particles with or without FCPs. These results suggested that loading of FCPs on titania promoted the charge separation (
φ) and/or extended the lifetime of <TiO
2(e
−)> to reduce
Ithr and overall reaction rate, most probably by capturing electron(s). At the further lowered light intensity, the overall rate was markedly low enough not to be determined precisely.
Another feature of LID of photocatalytic activity of r-c-S. The rage became almost constant, i.e., zero-order LID was observed at ca. ln
I = 3. Although this cannot be explained in the above-mentioned kinetic model, the reaction step of two electron-bearing titania (Equation (5)) requires the presence of oxygen to accept those electrons. At the higher intensity region, concentration of oxygen near the surface of FCP particles might become very low or even almost zero and thereby the overall reaction rate might be oxygen-diffusion limited. At the further higher intensity, the overall rate was increased again with the increase in light intensity. Since the diffusion of oxygen to the surface of FCP deposits have been already limited, such increase in the overall rate must be induced by oxygen reduction, presumably four-electron process, on the surface of titania, but not on FCPs. In such a case, LID of photoabsorption and overall rate may be fourth order and second order, respectively, and this seems consistent with the results shown in
Figure 8.
3. Materials and Methods
3.1. Material Preparation
All of the chemical reagents used in this experiment were of analytical grade and used without further purification.
In a typical synthesis, given amounts of polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP; 0 g, 3.333 g (MW 40,000), or 3.333 g (MW 29,000), Sigma-Aldrich, St Louis, MO, USA) were dissolved into a 100-mL aqueous solution of copper(II) chloride (CuCl2; 0.01 mol L−1, Wako Pure Chemical Industries, Osaka, Japan). Then, a 10.0-mL aqueous sodium hydroxide (NaOH, Wako Pure Chemical Industries, Osaka, Japan) solution (2.0 mol L−1) was added into the above-mentioned transparent solution. Then a 10-mL ascorbic-acid solution (0.6 mol L−1, Wako Pure Chemical Industries, Osaka, Japan) was added dropwise into the mixture. The mixture was aged for 3 h. Samples synthesized at a given temperature of 328 K are denoted as “c”, “co” and “o”, while samples synthesized by the identical process at room temperature (298 K) are denoted as “r-c”, “r-co” and “r-o”. The resulting precipitate was collected by centrifugation, followed by washing with distilled water and absolute ethanol, and finally dried in vacuum at 333 K for 5 h for further characterization.
In a typical synthesis, a 1.764-g portion of titania (ST-G2, Showa Denko Ceramics, Toyama, Japan, size: 500 nm) powder was suspended in a 50.0-mL aqueous solution of CuCl2 (0.0l mol L−1). The theoretical loading amount of faceted Cu2O particles was 2 wt%. Given amounts of PVP (0 g, 1.6665g (MW 40,000), or 1.6665g (MW 29,000)) were dissolved into the suspension. Then, 5.0-mL aqueous NaOH solution (2.0 mol L−1) was added into the suspension. Then a 5-mL ascorbic acid-solution (0.6 mol L−1) was added dropwise into the suspension. The mixture was aged for 3 h. Samples synthesized in a water bath at a given temperature of 328 K are denoted as “c-S”, “co-S” and “o-S”, while samples synthesized by the identical process at room temperature (298 K) are denoted as “r-c-S”, “r-co-S” and “r-o-S”. The resulting precipitate was collected by centrifugation, followed by washing with distilled water and absolute ethanol, and finally dried in vacuum at 333 K for 5 h for further characterization.
The photodeposition method was used to deposit platinum on titania (ST-G2), where the identical method developed by our group was followed [
26]. A 600-mg portion of the titania was suspended in 28.6 mL of 50 vol% aqueous methanol. Hexachloroplatinic acid (Wako Pure Chemical Industries, Osaka, Japan) was dropwise added into the suspension to make platinum (Pt) deposited on titania during photoirradiation. The loading amount of Pt was maintained to be 2 wt%. The obtained Pt-loaded titania were denoted as “Pt-S”. The suspension was purged of air with argon for 10 min in a test tube. A 400-W high-pressure mercury lamp (Eiko-sha, Tokyo, Japan) under thermostatic control at room temperature was used as an irradiation light source. The amount of evolved hydrogen (H
2) was measured by gas chromatography—thermal conductivity detector (GC-TCD, Shimadzu, Kyoto, Japan). For comparison, bare commercial copper(I) oxide (Wako Pure Chemical Industries, Osaka, Japan) was physically mixed with titania (ST-G2) in an agate mortar, denoted as “b-S”, and the loading amount of bare copper (I) oxide was 2 wt%.
3.2. Material Characterizations
The morphology was characterized by field-emission scanning electron microscopy (FE-SEM; JEOL JSM-7400F, JEOL, Tokyo, Japan). The elemental analysis of synthesized materials was performed by energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS, equipped in the FE-SEM, JED-2300, JEOL, Tokyo, Japan). The phase composition and crystallinity were measured by X-ray diffraction (XRD, Rigaku, Tokyo, Japan). Powder X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis was performed using a Rigaku SmartLab diffractometer equipped with a sealed tube X-ray generator (a copper target; operated at 40 kV and 30 mA), a D/teX high-speed position-sensitive detector system and an ASC-10 automatic sample changer. All of the XRD measurements were performed under the following conditions: 2θ range, 10°–90°; scan speed, 1.00° min−1; and scan step, 0.008°. The obtained XRD patterns were analyzed by Rigaku PDXL software(Rigaku, Tokyo, Japan), including the Rietveld analysis package, installed in a computer controlling the diffractometer. The optical property of synthesized materials was measured by diffuse reflectance spectroscopy (DRS, JASCO V-670 spectrophotometer equipped with a PIN-757 integrating sphere, JASCO, Tokyo, Japan) with barium sulfate as a reference.
3.3. Photocatalytic Activity Measurement
Photocatalytic activities of prepared photocatalysts were examined for photocatalytic carbon-dioxide (CO2) liberation by oxidative decomposition of acetic acid. A 50-mg portion of a photocatalyst was suspended in a 5-mL 5.0vol% aqueous acetic-acid solution(Wako Pure Chemical Industries, Osaka, Japan) and irradiated with a 400-W high-pressure mercury lamp under vigorous magnetic stirring (1000 rpm). The amount of liberated CO2 gas was measured by gas chromatography—thermal conductivity detector (GC-TCD, Shimadzu, Kyoto, Japan). Light-intensity dependence was measured in the CO2 system using 30 mg of sample powder suspended in 3-mL of 5.0vol% aqueous acetic-acid solution. A UV-LED emitting light of wavelength of 365 nm (NS Lighting ULDEN101, NS Lighting, Tokyo, Japan) was used as the illumination source, and the light-intensity dependence of the rate of CO2 liberation was measured.