Efficient Synthesis of 2-OH Thioglycosides from Glycals Based on the Reduction of Aryl Disulfides by NaBH4
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
In this study, the authors reported an one-pot method to efficiently synthesize 2-OH thioaryl glycosides starting from corresponding per-protected glycals and disulfides, via 1,2-anhydro sugars intermediate. This method has been further used to synthesize glycosyl donors with both “armed” and “NGP (neighboring group participation)” effects’ groups on C2 position.
I find the work well conducted and the results worth being published. Some points could be improved to increase the overall quality of the manuscript. I list them here below:
1, P1 line 17: The first sentence in introduction, please reconsider "a major challenge" or "an important research topic".
2, P1 line 21: ---produce a product in the alfa or beta configuration, which will lead to --reduced yield and difficult purification----, may be use "and"
3, P1 line 26: --which leads to the beta-configuration---- it is not precise, may be can use "1,2-trans"
4, P2 figure 2: ZnCl2 should be ZnCl2.
5, P3 line 95: (1, 42%, 36 h) ,compound number should be bold.
6, P4 compounds numbers 4b-11b, 12b - 14b are not in accordance with the numbers in figure 4.
7, P7 line 198: In general process B, NaH is indispensable or not?
8, P14 line 595: the type for authors' name is not the same. H. Dong should be Dong, H.
9, P 15 line 619 and 646: Angew. Chem Int. Ed. should be Angew. Chem. Int. Ed.
Author Response
1, P1 line 17: The first sentence in introduction, please reconsider "a major challenge" or "an important research topic".
Answer: Good suggestion. We changed "a major challenge" as "an important research topic"
2, P1 line 21: ---produce a product in the alfa or beta configuration, which will lead to --reduced yield and difficult purification----, may be use "and"
Answer: Here "produce a product", so using "or" is right. When "produce a mixtue of two products", using "and" is right.
3, P1 line 26: --which leads to the beta-configuration---- it is not precise, may be can use "1,2-trans"
Answer: The reviewer is right. We have corrected it.
4, P2 figure 2: ZnCl2 should be ZnCl2.
Answer: The reviewer is right. We have corrected it.
5, P3 line 95: (1, 42%, 36 h) ,compound number should be bold.
Answer: The reviewer is right. We have corrected it.
6, P4 compounds numbers 4b-11b, 12b - 14b are not in accordance with the numbers in figure 4.
Answer: The reviewer is right. We have corrected them.
7, P7 line 198: In general process B, NaH is indispensable or not?
Answer: It is a cloudy solution. Most likely NaH is not completely soluble.
8, P14 line 595: the type for authors' name is not the same. H. Dong should be Dong, H.
Answer: The reviewer is right. We have corrected it.
9, P 15 line 619 and 646: Angew. Chem Int. Ed. should be Angew. Chem. Int. Ed.
Answer: The reviewer is right. We have corrected it.
Reviewer 2 Report
In this manuscript, Dong and co-workers report an efficient method for synthesis of 2-OH thioaryl glycosides by reduction of aryl disulfides with NaBH4. Furthermore, the C2-protected thioglycoside donors were also prepared in a one-pot reaction, and then used for glycosylation. Therefore, the results obtained in this study will have a sufficient impact for the readers of <molecules>, and I recommend publication of this manuscript after revision of the following points.
1. After checking the experimental procedure, it was found that 35~90 min should be needed for synthesis of 1 from compound 2. Thus, in the sentence (line 47~ 48) “As a result, 73% yield of 1 could be efficiently prepared from 2 over a 30-min reaction…” should be changed to “As a result, 73% yield of 1 could be efficiently prepared from 2 within 90 min…” or others.
2. In Figure 2 and Figure 6, “ZnCl2” and “NaBH4” should be changed to “ZnCl2” and “NaBH4” respectively.
3. In the whole text, the letter “D” in “D-glucopyranosides” should be changed to the small caps “d”.
4. In line 464, the color of ref [4d] should be corrected.
5. In SI, please check the grammar of the sentence “Synthesized in light of the reported reference”.
Author Response
- After checking the experimental procedure, it was found that 35~90 min should be needed for synthesis of 1 from compound 2. Thus, in the sentence (line 47~ 48) “As a result, 73% yield of 1 could be efficiently prepared from 2 over a 30-min reaction…” should be changed to “As a result, 73% yield of 1 could be efficiently prepared from 2 within 90 min…” or others.
Answer:The reviewer is right. We have corrected this sentence. - In Figure 2 and Figure 6, “ZnCl2” and “NaBH4” should be changed to “ZnCl2” and “NaBH4” respectively.
Answer:We have corrected these Figures. - In the whole text, the letter “D” in “D-glucopyranosides” should be changed to the small caps “d”.
Answer:We have corrected them. - In line 464, the color of ref [4d] should be corrected.
Answer:We have corrected it. - In SI, please check the grammar of the sentence “Synthesized in light of the reported reference”.
Answer:what we used here is an incomplete sentence. The complete sentence is "The compound is synthesized in light of the reported reference."
Reviewer 3 Report
The paper is written very well, it is clear and concise. I appreciate authors for screening and optimizing different solvents. I have a question for authors i.e. When you use ACN as solvent did authors observe any amide formation (attack of N from ACN molecule to the 1,2-anhydro glucose 3) in addition to thioaryl product.
Author Response
Answers to the reviewer:
We did not observe any attacking of N from ACN molecule to the 1,2-anhydro glucose. However, we did observe a coupling reaction between acetonitrile and BnBr in the presence of sodium hydride in the process of synthesizing tri-OBn glycals.