3.1. Rheological Analysis
Asphalt is a typical viscoelastic material. Its mechanical behavior is affected by temperature and frequency, and it has equivalent viscoelastic properties under high temperatures and low frequencies and under low temperatures and high frequencies, which conforms to the time–temperature superposition principle (TTSP). Based on the idea of TTSP, this paper combines the (1) CAM equation with the (3) WLF equation and moves the results of the frequency scanning tests at different temperatures to the reference temperatures of 10 °C and 60 °C in order to obtain the viscoelastic mechanical behavior of asphalt at a wider range of temperatures and frequencies. The main curves of the complex shear moduli of the three bitumen are shown in
Figure 3. In the figure: B stands for base asphalt; SBS stands for SBS modified asphalt; AN stands for base asphalt with the anti-stripping agent added; the suffix A stands for long-term aging; and UA stands for unaged. This marking method is used uniformly in the subsequent charts.
In the formula:
is the asphalt glass shear modulus;
K and
m are the main curve fitting parameters;
is the main curve fitting parameter of loading frequency; and
is the conversion loading frequency according to Equation (2).
In the formula: is the actual loading frequency, and is the temperature shift factor.
From the main curves of the complex moduli, it can be seen that regardless of the kind of asphalt, whether base asphalt, modified asphalt or asphalt with the anti-stripping agent, the complex moduli increase after aging; moreover, the increases are more obvious in the low frequency range, and the increases in the high frequency range basically coincide with those before aging. When the temperatures are the same, the loading frequency increases, and the complex moduli of the asphalts increase accordingly; when the temperatures are different, under the same loading frequency, the complex moduli at low temperature are higher than those at high temperature. Compared with 10 °C, the change degree of the asphalt moduli before and after aging at 60 °C is smaller, indicating that the asphalt modulus is more affected by temperature than aging.
In
Figure 3b, the increase in the complex modulus of the SBS modified asphalt after aging is significantly lower than that of the base asphalt, indicating that long-term aging has a greater impact on the base asphalt than SBS modified asphalt. In
Figure 3c, the asphalt with the anti-stripping agent is similar to the SBS asphalt. At 10 °C, the increase in the complex modulus is slightly higher than that of the SBS modified asphalt and significantly smaller than that of the base asphalt. This shows that the anti-aging ability of the anti-stripping-agent asphalt is better than that of the base asphalt and slightly worse than that of the SBS modified asphalt. At 60 °C, the main curves of the complex modulus before and after the aging of the asphalt with the anti-stripping agent basically overlap. This indicates that the improvement of the anti-stripping agent on asphalt aging resistance is also affected by temperature, and the higher the temperature the more obvious the improvement of the anti-stripping agent on asphalt aging resistance.
In addition, based on the time–temperature equivalence principle, the temperature displacement factor equation WLF (3) can be used to obtain the shift factor of the complex modulus of asphalt in a wide frequency range at 10 °C and 60 °C, which can better illustrate the variation in the dynamic rheology of asphalt materials at different temperatures. The calculation results are shown in
Table 3.
In the formula: αT is the temperature shift factor; t is the test temperature, °C; Tg is the reference temperature; and °C; C1, and C2 are constants.
Table 3.
WLF formula parameters table.
Table 3.
WLF formula parameters table.
Temperature/°C | Parameter | | | Type | | |
---|
B-A | B-UA | SBS-A | SBS-UA | AN-A | AN-UA |
---|
10 | C1 | −18.5 | −20.5 | −19.5 | −20.6 | −20.5 | −20.5 |
C2 | 142 | 140.2 | 144.3 | 144.8 | 142 | 142 |
60 | C1 | −10.3 | −10.5 | −9.5 | −9.8 | −10.02 | −10.22 |
C2 | 149.6 | 152.3 | 144.3 | 144.7 | 150.97 | 152.01 |
Analysis of shift factors C
1 and C
2 in
Table 3 shows that the shift factors C
1 and C
2 of the base asphalt before and after aging at 10 °C changed by 10.81% and 1.28%, respectively, and shows that the C
1 and C
2 values of the SBS modified asphalt changed by 5.64% and 0.35%, respectively. However, adding the anti-stripping agent to the asphalt produced basically no changes to C
1 and C
2. At 60 °C, the differences between the three asphalts before and after aging are very small, indicating that the effect of temperature on the modulus is greater than that of aging. When the temperature reaches a certain level, aging has little effect on the modulus of asphalt.
3.2. Chemical Composition Analysis
Figure 4 shows the infrared spectra of the three asphalts before and after aging, and
Table 4 shows the transmittance values of some characteristic peaks. The base asphalt, SBS modified asphalt and asphalt mixed with the anti-stripping agent all showed strong absorption peaks at 2920 cm
−1, 2850 cm
−1, 1456 cm
−1 and 1376 cm
−1, among which there are two distinct absorption peaks in the range of 2800 cm
−1~3000 cm
−1. Different characteristic peaks correspond to different functional groups, which indicate that C-H is the host in the three asphalts. These strong absorption peaks are caused by the C-H bond vibrations in the alkanes and cycloalkanes and the -CH
2-stretching vibrations at wave numbers 2920 cm
−1 and 2850 cm
−1. The absorption peak at wave number 1600 cm
−1 represents the C=O double bond in the carbonyl group, and the content here can reflect the aging degree of the asphalt to a certain extent [
35]. At the same time, when the benzene ring skeleton vibrates, the conjugated double bond C=C also affects the absorption peak there. The absorption peaks at 1456 cm
−1 and 1376 cm
−1 are caused by the in-plane stretching vibration of C-H and C-CH
3 in –CH
2−, respectively. The absorption peak at wave number 1030 cm
−1 is the sulfoxide-based S=O double bond. Like the C=O double bond, the intensity of the absorption peak here can also reflect the degree of aging. Wave numbers from 910 cm
−1 to 650 cm
−1 are benzene ring substitution regions, and the C-H out-of-plane rocking vibrations form several absorption peaks.
Studies have shown that aging is mainly caused by high temperature action and oxidation reaction, which is manifested as an increase in the number of oxygen-containing functional groups, such as carbonyl and sulfoxide [
36]. Among the three asphalts, there is a clear absorption peak at wavenumber 965 cm
−1 for the SBS modified asphalt in
Figure 4 (b), which does not appear in either
Figure 4a or
Figure 4c and which corresponds to butadiene in the SBS modifier.
As shown in
Figure 4a, the overall trends of decreasing transmittance and increasing intensity of the absorption peaks after aging of the base asphalt indicate that the content of the functional groups increases, with increases of 2.56% and 7.08% at wavenumbers 1600 cm
−1 and 1030 cm
−1, respectively, being particularly obvious. This shows that the content of the S=O double bonds and C=O double bonds increases after the aging of the base asphalt, and the chemical composition becomes larger, which is consistent with the dynamic rheological test results. Compared with the base asphalt, in
Figure 4b, the SBS modified asphalt shows little change in infrared spectral transmittance after aging, indicating that its internal structure is stable and that it has a strong anti-aging ability. At wave numbers 1600 cm
−1 and 1030 cm
−1, the enhancements were 0.1% and 0.23%, respectively, indicating that the SBS modifier weakened the oxidation reaction during the aging process of the asphalt.
As shown in
Figure 4c, the content of the functional groups in the asphalt mixed with the anti-stripping agent changes to a certain extent before and after aging, and the degree of change is between those of the base asphalt and the SBS modified asphalt. The changes in its absorption peak intensities are relatively complex. Combined with the analysis of the functional group content in
Table 4, all absorption peak intensities are enhanced after the aging of the base asphalt and SBS modified asphalt. However, the absorption peaks at 2920 cm
−1 and 2850 cm
−1 for the asphalt mixed with the anti-stripping agent are enhanced, which is the same as those of base asphalt and SBS modified asphalt; moreover, the absorption peaks at 1600 cm
−1, 1456 cm
−1, 1376 cm
−1 and 1030 cm
−1 weakened, contrary to the other two at 1030 cm
−1 and 1600 cm
−1, which weakened by 1.01% and 1.43%, respectively. That is, the content of the C=O double bond in the carbonyl group and the S=O double bond in the sulfoxide group decreased, indicating that the addition of the anti-stripping agent makes the C=O double bond and the S=O double bond in the asphalt molecule unstable and that an aging reaction occurred during the process resulting in a reduction in the content.
In order to distinguish the anti-aging properties of the three asphalts more clearly, the absorption peak areas around 1600 cm
−1 and 1030 cm
−1 were taken as the absorption peaks of the carbonyl and sulfoxide groups, respectively, and the normalized carbonyl index (NCI) and normalized sulfoxide index (NSI) were used to quantitatively analyze the anti-aging properties of the three asphalts. Compared with the carbonyl index (CI) and sulfoxide index (SI), the NCI and NSI overcome the drift of the initial values of the CI and SI and can reflect the changes in the asphalt with aging time more clearly [
37]. The specific calculation methods of the aging indices are shown in
Table 5. In the table: CI
0 and CI
t represent the carbonyl indices before and after long-term aging, respectively; SI
0 and SI
t represent the sulfoxide indices before and after long-term aging, respectively; A
C=O is the carbonyl absorption peak area; A
S=O is the sulfoxide absorption peak area; and ΣA is a total peak area between 2000 cm
−1 and 600 cm
−1. The calculation results of the NCI and NSI of each asphalt after long-term aging are shown in
Table 6.
It can be seen from
Table 6 that the NCI and NSI of the base asphalt are significantly higher than those of the SBS modified asphalt, indicating that the carbonyl and sulfoxide groups generated by the SBS modified asphalt during the long-term aging process are less than those of the base asphalt, which is consistent with the qualitative analysis results of the infrared spectrum in this section. The addition of the anti-stripping agent slightly improves the aging resistance of the base asphalt probably because the fatty acids in the anti-stripping agent play a role similar to that of active antioxidants, inhibiting the reaction between polar groups in the asphalt and thus slowing down the aging of the asphalt.
3.3. Surface Micromorphology Analysis
Figure 5 and
Figure 6 show the two-dimensional surface topography and three-dimensional elevation maps, respectively, of the three asphalts before and after aging.
Table 7 shows the topographic parameters obtained using NanoScope Analysis software. The root mean square roughness, Rq, and the arithmetic mean difference, Ra, of the surface profile were selected to characterize the three-dimensional topographic features, and the height differences and the maximum honeycomb structure length are used for auxiliary analysis.
Observing
Figure 5, we can see a large number of honeycomb structures. Relevant studies have shown that honeycomb structures on the microscopic surface of asphalt are crystals formed by the eutectic interaction between wax molecules and the side chain alkyl groups of macromolecular substances, such as asphaltenes and colloids [
38]. From the comparison of the two-dimensional morphology, it is obvious that the anti-stripping-agent doped asphalt is different from the other two. The honeycomb structures of the base asphalt (a) and SBS (b) modified asphalt before aging are relatively scattered and mostly short and coarse, while the honeycomb structures become longer and the number of peaks increases slightly after long-term aging (as shown in
Figure 5d,e); however, the anti-stripping-agent doped asphalt (c) does not see any honeycomb structures before aging, although after aging (f) there appeared some, presumably because the asphalt internal asphaltene is increasing due to aging, which provides crystalline cores for wax molecules and thus produces honeycomb structures.
In order to more clearly show the evolution of the microstructures of the anti-stripping-agent asphalt before and after aging, AFM three-dimensional images were introduced to assist in the analysis, as shown in
Figure 6. Observing the three-dimensional morphology of
Figure 6, it can be seen that the heights and undulations of each region of the base asphalt and SBS modified asphalt tend to decrease with aging, presumably due to the weakening of the physical or chemical interactions between the parts due to long-term aging; moreover, the convergence of chemically similar components and the weakening of the connections between the regions, which in turn leads to the distribution of each region becoming independent and dispersed, and the macroscopic aspects are manifested as increased stability, such as high temperature stability and softening point enhancement [
39].
From
Figure 6 and
Table 7, it can be concluded that the relative height difference of the base asphalt increases by 50.17% after aging, and the Rq and Ra increased by 10.44% and 10.73%, respectively, indicating that the roughness of the base asphalt increases after long-term aging. This may be because in the long-term aging process, the molecular chain of the base asphalt is damaged and reorganized, the relative molecular mass of the asphalt increases and the light components in the asphalt volatilize, so long-term aging makes the asphalt appear rough [
40]. The number of honeycomb structures increased after the long-term aging of the SBS modified asphalt, and the Rq and Ra increased by 7.53% and 29.46%, respectively. After the anti-stripping agent was added to the base asphalt, the honeycomb structures on the surface of the asphalt disappeared, and only two highly different phases could be distinguished with a three-dimensional topography map moreover, the Rq and Ra of the honeycomb structures were much smaller than those of the base asphalt and SBS modified asphalt. While the honeycomb structures reappeared on the surface of the anti-stripping-agent asphalt after long-term aging, the Rq and Ra increased about 3.5 and 2.9 times, respectively; however, the value of the honeycomb structures is still significantly smaller than those of the aged base asphalt and SBS modified asphalt, and the amount of honeycomb structures is more than that of the aged base asphalt and less than that of the aged SBS modified asphalt, which is between the two. Through the above analysis quantitatively and qualitatively, the effects of aging on the micromorphology of asphalt were explored, and the results show that aging causes dramatic changes in the microsurface structures and honeycomb structures of asphalt, which in turn affected its macroscopic properties.