Expert and Diffuse Design of a Sustainable Circular Economy in Two German Circular Roadmap Projects
John McEldowney
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
An interesting and useful paper, worthy of publication.
Comments for author File: 
Comments.pdf
Author Response
Reviewer 1 asks for no changes
Reviewer 2 Report
Some suggestions to improve the paper:
1. Research question\questions are missing in the Intro section. Please clarify the RQs which should sound clear and specific. Also it is always important to highlight the novelty\originality of the paper.
2. This research should be restructured. Please follow IMRaD format.
3. There is no separate section describing Research Methods. Please revise accordingly.
4. It is necessary to enhance this study with visual materials and also tables, if applicable.
5. What is the practical implication of this study? Please clarify in the Discussion section which could be added.
6. The findings of the study should be highlighted in the Conclusion section.
Author Response
Reviewer 2 notes and answers
- Research question\questions are missing in the Intro section.Please clarify the RQs which should sound clear and specific. Also it is always important to highlight the novelty\originality of the paper. Research Questions added
- This research should be restructured. Please follow IMRaD format. Abstract reformulated to IMRAd format
- There is no separate section describing Research Methods. Please revise accordingly. Research Methods section included
- It is necessary to enhance this study with visual materials and also tables, if applicable. There is limited or no scope to do so given word length
- What is the practical implication of this study? Please clarify in the Discussion section which could be added. Practical implication added
- The findings of the study should be highlighted in the Conclusion section. Findings highlighted
