Next Article in Journal
Active Autophagy Is Associated with Favorable Outcome in Patients with Surgically Resected Cholangiocarcinoma
Next Article in Special Issue
Safety of Boron Neutron Capture Therapy with Borofalan(10B) and Its Efficacy on Recurrent Head and Neck Cancer: Real-World Outcomes from Nationwide Post-Marketing Surveillance
Previous Article in Journal
Regulation of IGF1R by MicroRNA-15b Contributes to the Anticancer Effects of Calorie Restriction in a Murine C3-TAg Model of Triple-Negative Breast Cancer
Previous Article in Special Issue
Radiotherapy and Systemic Therapies: Focus on Head and Neck Cancer
 
 
Search for Articles:
Title / Keyword
Author / Affiliation / Email
Journal
Article Type
 
 
Advanced Search
 
Section
Special Issue
Volume
Issue
Number
Page
 
Journals
Cancers
Volume 15
Issue 17
10.3390/cancers15174321
cancers-logo
Submit to this Journal Review for this Journal Propose a Special Issue
► Article Menu

Article Menu

share Share announcement Help format_quote Cite question_answer Discuss in SciProfiles thumb_up
...
Endorse textsms
...
Comment
first_page
settings
Order Article Reprints
Font Type:
Arial Georgia Verdana
Font Size:
Aa Aa Aa
Line Spacing:
Column Width:
Background:
Systematic Review

Hypothyroidism following Radiotherapy for Head and Neck Cancer: A Systematic Review of the Literature and Opportunities to Improve the Therapeutic Ratio

by
Michael K. Rooney
*,
Lauren M. Andring
,
Kelsey L. Corrigan
,
Vincent Bernard
,
Tyler D. Williamson
,
Clifton D. Fuller
,
Adam S. Garden
,
Brandon Gunn
,
Anna Lee
,
Amy C. Moreno
,
William H. Morrison
,
Jack Phan
,
David I. Rosenthal
,
Michael Spiotto
and
Steven J. Frank
Department of Radiation Oncology, MD Anderson Cancer Center, Houston, TX 77030, USA
*
Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.
Cancers 2023, 15(17), 4321; https://doi.org/10.3390/cancers15174321
Submission received: 18 July 2023 / Revised: 23 August 2023 / Accepted: 25 August 2023 / Published: 29 August 2023
(This article belongs to the Special Issue Advances in Radiotherapy for Head and Neck Cancer)
Browse Figures
Review Reports Versions Notes

Abstract

:

Simple Summary

Hypothyroidism is a common toxicity experienced after radiotherapy for head and neck malignancies. In this systemic review of the literature, we consolidated the body of existing evidence regarding the incidence and risk factors for radiotherapy-induced hypothyroidism. We found large variations in estimates, although the most recent large investigations suggest an overall incidence of approximately 40–50%, which is significantly higher than many historical estimates. Furthermore, we synthesized the evidence regarding the dosimetric-based prediction of hypothyroidism, including a summary of various proposed dosimetric parameters that may be utilized clinically to optimize plans. We found a paucity of literature investigating the use of modern advanced radiotherapy techniques, such as particle therapy or MRI-guided radiotherapy, to reduce the risk of thyroid toxicity. These findings may be useful to guide clinicians and researchers aiming to improve the care of patients undergoing radiotherapy for head and neck cancer.

Abstract

(1) Background: Radiotherapy (RT) is a central component for the treatment of many head and neck cancers. In this systematic review of the literature, we aimed to characterize and quantify the published evidence on RT-related hypothyroidism, including estimated incidence, clinical risk factors, and dosimetric parameters that may be used to guide clinical decision making. Furthermore, we aimed to identify potential areas of improvement in the prevention and clinical management of RT-induced hypothyroidism, including the role of modern advanced therapeutic techniques. (2) Methods: We conducted a systemic review of the literature in accordance with Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis (PRISMA) guidelines. PubMed and Google Scholar were searched to identify original research articles describing the incidence, mechanism, dosimetry, treatment, or prevention of radiation-related hypothyroidism for adults receiving RT for the treatment of head and neck cancers. The snowball method was used to identify additional articles. For identified articles, we tabulated several datapoints, including publication date, patient sample size, estimated hypothyroidism incidence, cancer site/type, follow-up period, radiation modality and technique, use of multimodality therapy, method of thyroid function evaluation, and proposed dosimetric predictors of hypothyroidism. (3) Results: One hundred and eleven articles met inclusion criteria, reflecting a range of head and neck cancer subtypes. There was a large variation in the estimated incidence of RT-related hypothyroidism, with a median estimate of 36% (range 3% to 79%). Reported incidence increased in later publication dates, which was likely related to improved screening and longer follow up. There were a wide variety of predictive metrics used to identify patients at high risk of hypothyroidism, the most common of which were volumetric and mean dosimetrics related to the thyroid gland (Vxx%, Dmean). More recently, there has been increasing evidence to suggest that the thyroid gland volume itself and the volume of the thyroid gland spared from high-dose radiation (VSxx) may better predict thyroid function after RT. There were no identified studies investigating the role of advanced radiotherapeutic techniques such as MRI-guided RT or particle therapy to decrease RT-related hypothyroidism. Conclusions: Hypothyroidism is a common toxicity resulting from therapeutic radiation for head and neck cancer with recent estimates suggesting 40–50% of patients may experience hypothyroidism after treatment. Dosimetric predictive models are increasingly able to accurately identify patients at risk of hypothyroidism, especially those utilizing thyroid VS metrics. Further investigation regarding the potential for advanced radiotherapeutic therapies to decrease RT-induced thyroid dysfunction is needed.

1. Introduction

Hypothyroidism is a common complication that can occur after radiation therapy for head and neck cancers. The thyroid gland is particularly vulnerable to the damaging effects of radiation, which can result in a decrease in thyroid hormone production and the development of hypothyroidism. This in turn can lead to impairments in quality of life, including altered general body metabolism, decreased general health perception, worse emotional well-being, cognitive impairment, fatigue, and sexual dysfunction, among others [1,2]. Furthermore, impaired thyroid function has been associated with increased overall risk of mortality [3,4]. Treatment for hypothyroidism often requires lifelong hormone replacement, which itself can contribute to worse perceived quality of life and financial burden not only via direct medication costs but also due to recurrent healthcare visits and laboratory testing. Importantly, thyroid replacement therapy also may be ineffective in as many as 20% of patients due to a variety of causes such as gastrointestinal disease, drug interaction, and non-compliance [5]. Such situations may require more complex treatment strategies to normalize thyroid function. Therefore, the accurate prediction of patients at higher risk of hypothyroidism, and ideally optimization of treatment to decrease such risk, are paramount to improve outcomes for patients receiving radiotherapy for head and neck cancers.
Hypothyroidism has historically been defined using several approaches. Most generically is the clinical definition of hypothyroidism specified by the presence of signs or symptoms related to an underactive thyroid gland such as weight gain, cold intolerance, and fatigue. It also has been described more specifically using biochemical definitions based upon serum levels of thyroxine (T4) and thyrotropin or thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) [6]. Classical biochemical hypothyroidism refers to decreased T4 with elevated TSH regardless of clinical symptoms. Biochemically, subclinical hypothyroidism refers to a normal level of T4 in the setting of an elevated TSH [7]. However, specific reported measurements and value ranges may differ according to laboratory measurement techniques, and thus, there may be variation in absolute reported hormone levels across institutions. Given such heterogeneity, for the purposes of this review, we avoided any quantitative analysis of hormone levels and rather categorized hypothyroidism diagnoses based upon the method of evaluation. Any diagnosis that was based purely on clinical symptoms without requirement for biochemical evaluation was considered clinical hypothyroidism and any biochemical presence of underactive thyroid function, including classic subclinical hypothyroidism (elevated TSH with normal T4), was considered biochemical hypothyroidism. Ultimately, regardless of method of evaluation, the decision to prescribe thyroid hormone supplementation is the critical clinical decision-making point that will have implications for patient management strategies and outcomes.
The objective of this review was to systematically analyze the available literature on the incidence, patient- and treatment-related risk factors, and consequences of hypothyroidism after head and neck radiation therapy. The results of this review may have important implications for the management and care of patients undergoing head and neck radiation therapy and may contribute to the development of strategies to minimize the risk of treatment-related hypothyroidism.

2. Materials and Methods

2.1. Search Protocol and Article Identification

We created a systematic review protocol in accordance with Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis (PRISMA) guidelines (Figure 1) [8,9]. This protocol has not been registered. We used the Medical Subject Headings (MeSH) and generic search terms to generate the initial PubMed search query on 26 November 2022: (((radiotherapy) OR (radiation therapy)) AND (head and neck)) AND ((thyroid) OR (hypothyroidism) OR (thyroid toxicity) OR (thyroid dysfunction)). Only full research articles were included and no restrictions were made with regard to publication date. Resulting articles were screened initially by abstract review and subsequent review of the full article. Only original articles that were available in English and obtainable for review by the authors were included. Articles were evaluated for inclusion based upon the follow criteria: must report on original research describing the incidence, mechanism, dosimetry, management, or prevention of radiation-relation hypothyroidism for adults receiving RT as a component of treatment for head and neck cancer. Studies reporting on thyroid cancer were excluded. Two reviewers (MKR and KLC) independently reviewed and screened articles for inclusion.
Eighty studies were identified using this initial search and article evaluation. In order to develop a more robust search method, we additionally searched the Google Scholar database using the query “hypothyroidism after radiation therapy” and evaluated the first 500 results. We again applied the evaluation criteria to identify unique articles that were not found in the PubMed search.
Finally, the snowball method was utilized to identity any remaining publications not included in the initial two search protocols [10]. The snowball procedure refers to the evaluation of referenced literature of already identified articles and has been shown to result in the more accurate and exhaustive identification of desired articles [11]. In this review protocol, we reviewed 955 references from the initially included 97 publications and identified 14 additional unique publications.

2.2. Article Evaluation and Data Collection

For included articles, we tabulated the following data: first author, publication year, study design (categorized as prospective or retrospective), interventional study (yes/no), study participant (patients or physicians), estimated hypothyroidism incidence (%), sample size, study follow up, head and neck cancer subsite, radiation modality, radiation technique, allowance of multimodality therapy, method for thyroid function evaluation, proposed dosimetric or volumetric risk factor, and other relevant clinical findings.
A study was deemed to be interventional if it described a technique or evaluation of a procedure aimed at preventing or treating RT-induced hypothyroidism. Study follow up was recorded as specifically as possible according to the information presented in the publication. The cancer subsite was categorized as general head and neck cancer, nasopharynx, oropharynx, larynx/hypopharynx, and oral cavity. Radiation modality was recorded as photon, electron, proton, or carbon ion radiotherapy. The technique was categorized as either intensity-modulated radiotherapy (IMRT), MRI-guided radiotherapy, or other. After a full review of all studies, there were none that evaluated MRI-guided radiotherapy, so we report findings as either “IMRT” or “non-IMRT”, which includes 2D and 3D conformal radiotherapy (3DCRT). Multimodality therapy was considered treatment with surgery or systemic therapy in addition to radiation.
Various methods were described to evaluate and characterize thyroid function. We categorized approaches as follows: “biochemical” evaluation refers to the use of laboratory testing to measure hormone levels in the blood, “clinical” refers to the evaluation of symptoms of hypothyroidism or the need for clinical treatment with levothyroxine supplementation. There were also few instances where specific imaging modalities, such as ultrasound or positron emission tomography (PET), were used to evaluate endpoints related to thyroid structure or anatomy such as gland size, radiographic density, or PET avidity. These were characterized as “radiographic” methods and were not direct measures of thyroid function.
There were similarly a wide variety of methods describing predictive models for hypothyroidism. We tabulated all described dosimetric and volumetric parameters described in each article and categorized them in a post hoc fashion. Vxx% refers to the percent volume of the organ receiving a specified dose. Dxx refers to the dose received by a specific volume of the gland. Dmean refers to mean dose. The volume of thyroid gland that was spared by a particular dose (thus receiving that dose or less) was termed VSxx.

3. Results

We identified 111 publications that met inclusion criteria according to the search protocol. Characteristics of identified studies are summarized in Table 1. The individual studies are described in Supplementary Materials Table S1, with study sample sizes provided for each publication.

3.1. Estimated Incidence of RT-Induced Hypothyroidism

There was a large range of estimated rates of hypothyroidism following radiotherapy for head and neck cancer reported in the literature, although studies were heterogenous with different patient populations, treatment techniques, sample sizes, and methods/length of follow up. The median reported estimate for all studies was 36% (range 3% to 79%). The median reported mean or median follow-up time was described in 87 papers and was 32 months (IQR 21–50). There appeared to be a relationship between estimated incidence and publication date with more recent publications reporting higher incidence of hypothyroidism (Figure 2). Studies that reported hypothyroidism only based on clinical symptoms (n = 2) reported extremely low incidence (mean 4.9%). Additionally, studies with longer reported mean or median follow up were associated with increased estimated incidence of hypothyroidism (Figure 3).

3.2. Radiation Modality, Technique, and Dosimetric Predictors of Hypothyroidism

Of the studies that provided specific details regarding radiation modality, the vast majority (98%) reported photon radiotherapy, with a minority including combination (2%) photon/electron therapy. There were no studies identified that reported on the use of particle therapy. There was also a relatively even distribution of radiation techniques, including 2D or 3DCRT (34%) and IMRT (32%), or both (9%) with 24% of studies not specifying technique. It is difficult to ascertain the precise impact of radiation technique on the risk of hypothyroidism in these studies in aggregate due to significant confounding. IMRT was more likely to be utilized in modern studies, and such studies were also more likely to report a higher incidence of hypothyroidism.
Ten studies did include patients that received either 3DCRT or IMRT, of which seven provided a direct comparison of techniques. In six (86%), there were no significant differences in hypothyroidism incidence when comparing individuals receiving IMRT or 3DCRT. Notably, the study by Peng et al. randomized patients between modalities; unfortunately, thyroid function was only assessed clinically, and thus, thyroid dysfunction was exceptionally rare compared to other investigations using robust methods of thyroid evaluation (1.3% vs. 2.9% for IMRT vs. 3DCRT, respectively; p > 0.05) [12]. The only other study to report hypothyroidism incidence for patients randomized between modalities was by Murthy et al., who reported an increased risk of hypothyroidism with IMRT (51.1% vs. 27.3%, p = 0.021). However, the dose fractionation was different between arms with those receiving 3DCRT being prescribed 70 Gy in 2 Gy fractions and those receiving IMRT being prescribed 66 Gy in 2.2 Gy fractions [13].
Many investigators identified dosimetric parameters or developed dosimetric-based predictive models for the development of hypothyroidism. A summary of various proposed dosimetric planning constraints is summarized in Table 2.

3.3. Interventions Aimed at Preventing RT-Induced Hypothyroidism

Four studies were identified that investigated methods to prevent RT-induced hypothyroidism, three of which described a novel free thyroid transfer procedure to transplant the thyroid outside of the radiotherapy field. The proof-of-principle publication showed that it was possible to transfer the gland from the neck to the forearm for patients planned to undergo neck dissection, with successful transfer in 9 of 10 recruited patients, with results maintained at one year for all patients. The procedure added an additional 41.6 min of operative time without any reported additional surgical complications [50,51]. A subsequent publication replicated these results with six patients having the thyroid transferred to the thigh and five patients maintained euthyroid status at median follow up of 8 months [52]. We additionally identified one published prospective protocol investigating the use of amifostine, a recognized radioprotector, during radiotherapy to decrease the risk of developing hypothyroidism [53]. The results of the trial were not able to be identified in a subsequent publication.

3.4. Impact of Patient and Physician Factors on RT-Induced Hypothyroidism

Several patient-, treatment- and provider-related factors were associated with reported incidence and management of RT-induced hypothyroidism in the identified body of literature. Some studies (8%) reported that hypothyroidism was more common in females, with several publications suggesting that a decreased average thyroid volume in women was the likely causal factor explaining differences between sexes [31,54]. Furthermore, thyroid gland volume was associated with thyroid function and inversely related to the risk of subsequent hypothyroidism risk following RT. Several studies showed that greater decreases in thyroid volume or density changes following radiation therapy were predictive of subsequent hypothyroidism [30,55,56]. There was mixed evidence regarding the impact of patient age as a risk factor for subsequent hypothyroidism with some studies suggesting that younger age increased risk [57,58] while others suggesting the opposite relationship [27,59]. Combined modality therapy with radiotherapy, surgery, and chemotherapy was frequently reported to be associated with an increased development of hypothyroidism (15%).
There was a small subset of studies that investigated practice patterns of providers with regard to the diagnosis and management of RT-induced hypothyroidism. Lo Galbo et al. conducted a 2006 survey study of physicians in the Netherlands to assess when and how thyroid function tests were conducted after radiotherapy for head and neck cancer [60]. They found that 75% of physicians only tested patients when symptoms were mentioned. When screening, all physicians gathered thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH), while only 69% collected free T4 as well. The majority of respondents (65%) felt they would appreciate further guidance regarding screening practice. Rønjom et al. studied the impact of variation in target delineation of the thyroid gland among providers and the impact this may have on estimates of hypothyroidism using a normal tissue complication probability (NTCP) model [22]. They found that intra- and inter-observer variability in gland delineation did not have a significant impact on the performance of the toxicity prediction model; however, they do note that for any individual patient, there may be large differences in the estimated risk, and thus, the accurate delineation of the thyroid gland is critical for robust risk prediction.

4. Discussion

In this systematic review of the literature, we synthesized and characterized the current evidence regarding the incidence, clinical and dosimetric risk factors, and management and prevention strategies for RT-induced hypothyroidism for adults undergoing treatment of head and neck cancers. We found that the reported incidence of RT-related hypothyroidism has increased over time, which is likely owing to improved screening practice and longer follow up. Although there was wide variation in reported incidence, recent high- quality evidence suggests a rate of 40–50% for all patients with head and neck cancer receiving radiotherapy (Figure 1). Some investigations suggest that RT-induced hypothyroidism occurs relatively shortly after RT (e.g., within months), but others suggest that changes in function may occur for multiple years following treatment [43,44]. Many studies identified clinical and treatment-related factors that predict an increased risk of hypothyroidism, including female sex, decreased thyroid volume, and receipt of multimodality therapy. Furthermore, there is a growing body of research investigating the dosimetric prediction of thyroid dysfunction; early studies largely utilized volumetric thyroid gland parameters, such as V30–50, but more recent investigations suggest that thyroid volume-spared dosimetrics, for example TVS 50–60 Gy, may be the most robust predictors of subsequent toxicity. There were no studies identified by the search protocol that investigated the potential for advanced radiotherapeutic techniques including particle therapy or MRI-guided radiotherapy to decrease the risk of hypothyroidism. These findings may provide guidance for clinicians and researching aiming to improve outcomes for patients receiving RT for head and neck cancers.
The incidence of head and neck cancers has continued to increase with estimates of nearly 660,000 new cases per year, ranking as the seventh most common cancer globally [61]. Of those, it has been suggested that approximately 75% may benefit from radiotherapy [62,63,64]. Therefore, the effective prevention and management of treatment-related toxicity is critical, especially for common side effects which may impact large populations of patients. Hypothyroidism, as evidenced by the robust data in this review, is unfortunately an extremely common result of therapeutic radiation directed to the head and neck. Interestingly, our analysis does suggest that estimates of RT-related hypothyroidism have increased over time with the most recently published papers from 2020 and later estimating 40–50% for all comers, which is likely a result of increased screening (which may detect subclinical hypothyroidism) and longer follow up after treatment. These trends highlight the critical importance of maintaining awareness of this potential side effect to optimally screen patients for potential intervention. To our knowledge, there currently are no consensus guidelines from leading radiotherapy groups regarding optimal screening and management practices for RT-induced hypothyroidism. The data identified in this systematic review suggest a need for such guidelines to standardize practice among providers and improve functional outcomes for patients at large.
Although standardized guidelines regarding screening and management remain elusive, there are robust and growing data regarding the relationship between radiation dosimetry and subsequent thyroid dysfunction. In this review, we identified 38 manuscripts published since 2012 which propose various dosimetric predictors of hypothyroidism. The initial studies in this area largely focused on volumetric and mean constraints related to thyroid gland exposure, such as Dmean, Vxx (%), and Dxx. However, there has been a shift in the most recent analyses, with some reports suggesting that the volume of thyroid spared (VS) metrics outperforms other dosimetrics in terms of toxicity prediction [31,49]. Similar results have also been found in other disease sites such as Hodgkin’s lymphoma where the thyroid gland routinely receives therapeutic-range doses of radiotherapy [65]. Such trends could be explained by the physiologic function of the thyroid gland. As a parallel-functioning structure, the volume of normal glands that can avoid high-dose radiotherapy would intuitively predict the preservation of function. This hypothesis would also be supported by the frequent observation in the included studies that increased thyroid volume itself was protective against subsequent hypothyroidism. As such, we encourage the further research investigation of VS metrics as potential tools to optimize radiotherapy plans and suggest that clinicians consider the implementation of VS metrics as routine components of plan design and evaluation.
Given the clear relationship between radiation dose and risk of thyroid toxicity, improvements in the delivery of conformal radiotherapy will lead to improvements in the therapeutic ratio of head and neck radiation. Over the last several decades, there have been transformative improvements in the available radiation techniques to improve the quality of radiation plans. The most recent widely adopted technology has been IMRT, which allows for inverse-planned beam shaping to prioritize target coverage and minimize dose to organs-at-risk. Many large-scale randomized trials have indeed shown the benefits of IMRT in reducing acute and long-term side effects of radiation across multiple disease sites without compromising oncologic outcomes, including cervical cancer [66], endometrial cancer [67], and prostate cancer [68], among others.
In head and neck cancer, there have also been randomized trials investigating 3DCRT vs. IMRT that have shown a decreased incidence of side effects [69]. One randomized trial reported improvements in many RT-related toxicities, including xerostomia, hearing loss, temporal lobe neuropathy, cranial nerve palsy, trismus, and neck fibrosis with no significant difference in hypothyroidism between groups. However, the absolute incidence of hypothyroidism was 1.3% and 2.9% for 3DCRT and IMRT, respectively, which are both rates that were extremely low compared to other reports. This is likely owing to the fact that investigators only assessed for hypothyroidism with overt clinical symptoms as opposed to biochemical evaluation [12]. In a pooled analysis of two randomized trials, Murthy et al. interestingly found that rates of hypothyroidism were actually higher in patients receiving IMRT, although the authors acknowledge that the results are difficult to interpret for several reasons [13]. Dose and fractionation were different between the IMRT and 3DCRT cohorts; patients in the IMRT group received 66 Gy in 30 fractions and patients receiving 3DCRT were prescribed 70 Gy in 35 fractions. Radiobiologically, the thyroid gland is typically considered a late-responding tissue (therefore, alpha/beta is assumed to be ~3), and the biologically effective doses (BEDs) for these regimens are similar at 114.4 Gy and 116.67 Gy, respectively [70]. Furthermore, and most importantly, IMRT plans on these trials may not have used thyroid avoidance as a treatment planning goal and thus would not be expected to have improved toxicity with regard to the thyroid. Overall, in this review, we were unable to find any high-quality randomized data specifically comparing thyroid toxicity for patients receiving thyroid-sparing IMRT and 3DCRT. Nonetheless, many studies did show improved dosimetry with IMRT which, given the strong evidence discussed previously, would be expected to improve thyroid toxicity profiles through minimization of thyroid dose.
Although IMRT represents a significant advancement in radiation therapy technology, there have been other important developments which may further improve the ability to deliver therapeutic doses to targets while further decreasing the dose to nearby organs. Particle therapy, including proton and carbon ion therapy, is increasingly being investigated as a possible tool to decrease the toxicity of treatment through decreased dose to organs-at-risk. Many prospective and retrospective studies have shown improvements in other disease sites including pediatric cancers [71], esophageal cancer [72], and craniospinal irradiation for solid tumor leptomeningeal disease [73]. A recently completed randomized trial comparing IMRT and intensity-modulated proton therapy (IMPT) for the treatment of advanced oropharyngeal cancers (NCT01893307, PI Frank) will clarify the potential benefits of proton therapy for improving the toxicity of head and neck radiotherapy, including impact on hypothyroidism risk [74].
We also identified several exciting studies that aimed to develop surgical and medical techniques to prevent hypothyroidism after radiation. The free thyroid transfer technique was described by Harris et al. in 2016, in which patients who were planned to undergo neck dissection had their thyroid gland surgically removed and transferred to the forearm. The initial experience with this technique has been promising with the vast majority of patients maintaining a viable transplanted thyroid gland at one year post-procedure [50,51]. A second group reported a similar experience with free thyroid transfer to the thigh, with encouraging initial results [52]. From a clinical perspective, it is important to consider that these early reports to not provide evidence that transplanted thyroid glands maintain long-term endocrine function, and therefore, it is possible that some patients may require thyroxine supplementation despite undergoing the procedure. Additionally, the potential side effects of any additional surgical procedure must be weighed against medical management strategies for hypothyroidism, which in general have a benign side effect profile. As such, while these early studies do provide exciting preliminary evidence that this procedure is possible, longer-term studies with more rigorous evaluation of transplanted thyroid function will be necessary before the routine consideration of this procedure is warranted.
Our search protocol also identified a published clinical trial protocol investigating the use of amifostine to prevent hypothyroidism based upon preclinical data showing its role as a radioprotector [53]. Unfortunately, a subsequent publication of the trial findings was unable to be found. Nonetheless, the proposal to utilize radiomodulating agents, which have been commonly investigated in other settings, may representing a potential way to further decrease the risk of thyroid impairment.
Although this study draws strength from a rigorous search methodology that followed PRISMA guidelines and utilized the snowball technique to increase the search efficacy, it does have limitations. First, only two academic search engines were used; it is therefore possible that some scientific findings were missed that were published in other scientific fora. Second, we limited our search to English articles only and thus may have missed relevant publications in other languages. Third, there was significant heterogeneity in the reporting of some endpoints, which makes it difficult to synthesize findings in a meaningful way. For example, we would have aimed to holistically examine the trends in the detection of subclinical hypothyroidism over time, particularly in the modern era of increased screening. We unfortunately were unable to perform this analysis due to limitations in data reporting. Additionally, it would be clinically important to evaluate the utility of anti-thyroid peroxidase (TPO) antibody levels as a measure or predictor of RT-induced hypothyroidism. However, data regarding anti-TPO levels were rarely reported in the identified body of literature, and we were thus unable to meaningfully synthesize data to address this topic. Last, the search protocol was not replicated multiple times, and it is therefore possible that some individual articles were missed that would have otherwise met inclusion criteria.

5. Conclusions

In this systematic review of the literature, we found that RT-induced hypothyroidism is extremely common, with recent estimates of 40–50% utilizing high-quality thyroid function evaluation and long-term follow up. We highlighted several clinical and treatment-related factors that are associated with an increased risk of developing hypothyroidism, including female sex and decreased normal thyroid volume. Furthermore, we summarized the evidence regarding dosimetric-based toxicity prediction and recommend that clinicians consider the use of thyroid volume spared dosimetrics to optimize radiation plans, as these metrics appear to be the most robust predictors of RT-induced hypothyroidism in modern studies. Ongoing research will clarify the potential role for advanced techniques such as particle therapy and free-thyroid transfer to further reduce the risk of hypothyroidism. These findings can be used by providers and researchers alike to improve the care of patients with head and neck cancer by minimizing the symptom and financial burden associated with lifelong hypothyroidism after treatment.

Supplementary Materials

The following supporting information can be downloaded at: https://www.mdpi.com/article/10.3390/cancers15174321/s1, Table S1: List of all included articles.

Author Contributions

Conceptualization, M.K.R. and S.J.F.; methodology, M.K.R., L.M.A., K.L.C., V.B., T.D.W., C.D.F., A.S.G., B.G., A.L., A.C.M., W.H.M., J.P., D.I.R., M.S. and S.J.F.; software, M.K.R.; formal analysis, M.K.R.; investigation, M.K.R., L.M.A., K.L.C., V.B., T.D.W., C.D.F., A.S.G., B.G., A.L., A.C.M., W.H.M., J.P., D.I.R., M.S. and S.J.F.; resources, S.J.F.; data curation, M.K.R., L.M.A., K.L.C. and V.B.; writing—original draft preparation, M.K.R.; writing—review and editing, all authors; visualization, M.K.R.; supervision, S.J.F.; project administration, S.J.F. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.

Funding

This research received no external funding.

Institutional Review Board Statement

Not applicable.

Informed Consent Statement

Not applicable.

Data Availability Statement

Data will be made available upon reasonable request to the corresponding author.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflict of interest.

References

  1. Bianchi, G.; Zaccheroni, V.; Solaroli, E.; Vescini, F.; Cerutti, R.; Zoli, M.; Marchesini, G. Health-related quality of life in patients with thyroid disorders. Qual. Life Res. 2004, 13, 45–54. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  2. Watt, T.; Groenvold, M.; Rasmussen, A.K.; Bonnema, S.J.; Hegedüs, L.; Bjorner, J.B.; Feldt-Rasmussen, U. Quality of life in patients with benign thyroid disorders. A review. Eur. J. Endocrinol. 2006, 154, 501–510. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  3. Thvilum, M.; Brandt, F.; Almind, D.; Christensen, K.; Hegedüs, L.; Brix, T.H. Excess Mortality in Patients Diagnosed with Hypothyroidism: A Nationwide Cohort Study of Singletons and Twins. J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab. 2013, 98, 1069–1075. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  4. Bano, A.; Dhana, K.; Chaker, L.; Kavousi, M.; Ikram, M.A.; Mattace-Raso, F.U.S.; Peeters, R.P.; Franco, O.H. Association of Thyroid Function with Life Expectancy with and without Cardiovascular Disease: The Rotterdam Study. JAMA Intern. Med. 2017, 177, 1650–1657. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  5. Benvenga, S. When thyroid hormone replacement is ineffective? Curr. Opin. Endocrinol. Diabetes 2013, 20, 467–477. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  6. Chaker, L.; Bianco, A.C.; Jonklaas, J.; Peeters, R.P. Hypothyroidism. Lancet 2017, 390, 1550–1562. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  7. Peeters, R.P. Subclinical Hypothyroidism. N. Engl. J. Med. 2017, 376, 2556–2565. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  8. Moher, D.; Liberati, M.; Tetzlaff, J.; Altman, D.G.; PRISMA Group. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement. PLoS Med. 2009, 6, e1000097. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  9. Page, M.J.; McKenzie, J.E.; Bossuyt, P.M.; Boutron, I.; Hoffmann, T.C.; Mulrow, C.D.; Shamseer, L.; Tetzlaff, J.M.; Akl, E.A.; Brennan, S.E.; et al. The PRISMA 2020 Statement: An Updated Guideline for Reporting Systematic Reviews. BMJ 2021, 372, n71. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  10. Wohlin, C. Guidelines for Snowballing in Systematic Literature Studies and a Replication in Software Engineering. In Proceedings of the 18th International Conference on Evaluation and Assessment in Software Engineering, New York, NY, USA, 13–14 May 2014; ACM: London, UK, 2014; pp. 1–10. [Google Scholar]
  11. Greenhalgh, T.; Peacock, R. Effectiveness and efficiency of search methods in systematic reviews of complex evidence: Audit of primary sources. BMJ 2005, 331, 1064–1065. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  12. Peng, G.; Wang, T.; Yang, K.-Y.; Zhang, S.; Zhang, T.; Li, Q.; Han, J.; Wu, G. A prospective, randomized study comparing outcomes and toxicities of intensity-modulated radiotherapy vs. conventional two-dimensional radiotherapy for the treatment of nasopharyngeal carcinoma. Radiother. Oncol. 2012, 104, 286–293. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  13. Murthy, V.; Narang, K.; Ghosh-Laskar, S.; Gupta, T.; Budrukkar, A.; Agrawal, J.P. Hypothyroidism after 3-dimensional conformal radiotherapy and intensity-modulated radiotherapy for head and neck cancers: Prospective data from 2 randomized controlled trials. Head Neck 2014, 36, 1573–1580. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  14. Boomsma, M.J.; Bijl, H.P.; Christianen, M.E.; Beetz, I.; Chouvalova, O.; Steenbakkers, R.J.; van der Laan, B.F.; Wolffenbuttel, B.H.; Oosting, S.F.; Schilstra, C.; et al. A Prospective Cohort Study on Radiation-induced Hypothyroidism: Development of an NTCP Model. Int. J. Radiat. Oncol. 2012, 84, e351–e356. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  15. Rønjom, M.F.; Brink, C.; Bentzen, S.M.; Hegedüs, L.; Overgaard, J.; Johansen, J. Hypothyroidism after primary radiotherapy for head and neck squamous cell carcinoma: Normal tissue complication probability modeling with latent time correction. Radiother. Oncol. 2013, 109, 317–322. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  16. Bakhshandeh, M.; Hashemi, B.; Mahdavi, S.R.M.; Nikoofar, A.; Vasheghani, M.; Kazemnejad, A. Normal Tissue Complication Probability Modeling of Radiation-Induced Hypothyroidism after Head-and-Neck Radiation Therapy. Int. J. Radiat. Oncol. 2013, 85, 514–521. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  17. Huang, S.; Wang, X.; Hu, C.; Ying, H. Hypothalamic–pituitary–thyroid dysfunction induced by intensity-modulated radiotherapy (IMRT) for adult patients with nasopharyngeal carcinoma. Med. Oncol. 2013, 30, 710. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  18. Akgun, Z.; Atasoy, B.M.; Ozen, Z.; Yavuz, D.; Gulluoglu, B.; Sengoz, M.; Abacioglu, U. V30 as a predictor for radiation-induced hypothyroidism: A dosimetric analysis in patients who received radiotherapy to the neck. Radiat. Oncol. 2014, 9, 104. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  19. Kim, M.Y.; Yu, T.; Wu, H.-G. Dose-volumetric Parameters for Predicting Hypothyroidism after Radiotherapy for Head and Neck Cancer. Jpn. J. Clin. Oncol. 2014, 44, 331–337. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  20. Chyan, A.; Chen, J.; Shugard, E.; Lambert, L.; Quivey, J.M.; Yom, S.S. Dosimetric predictors of hypothyroidism in oropharyngeal cancer patients treated with intensity-modulated radiation therapy. Radiat. Oncol. 2014, 9, 269. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  21. Fujiwara, M.; Kamikonya, N.; Odawara, S.; Suzuki, H.; Niwa, Y.; Takada, Y.; Doi, H.; Terada, T.; Uwa, N.; Sagawa, K.; et al. The threshold of hypothyroidism after radiation therapy for head and neck cancer: A retrospective analysis of 116 cases. J. Radiat. Res. 2015, 56, 577–582. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  22. Rønjom, M.F.; Brink, C.; Lorenzen, E.L.; Hegedüs, L.; Johansen, J. Variation of normal tissue complication probability (NTCP) estimates of radiation-induced hypothyroidism in relation to changes in delineation of the thyroid gland. Acta Oncol. 2015, 54, 1188–1194. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  23. Pil, J.; Nevens, D.; Van Der Vorst, A.; Gadan, C.; Nuyts, S. The incidence of hypothyroidism after radiotherapy for head and neck cancer. B-ENT 2016, 12, 257–262. [Google Scholar] [PubMed]
  24. Luo, R.; Li, M.; Yang, Z.; Zhan, Y.; Huang, B.; Lu, J.; Xu, Z.; Lin, Z. Nomogram for radiation-induced hypothyroidism prediction in nasopharyngeal carcinoma after treatment. Br. J. Radiol. 2017, 90, 20160686. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  25. Lee, V.; Chan, S.-Y.; Choi, C.-W.; Kwong, D.; Lam, K.-O.; Tong, C.-C.; Sze, C.-K.; Ng, S.; Leung, T.-W.; Lee, A. Dosimetric Predictors of Hypothyroidism after Radical Intensity-modulated Radiation Therapy for Non-metastatic Nasopharyngeal Carcinoma. Clin. Oncol. 2016, 28, e52–e60. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  26. Ling, S.; Bhatt, A.D.; Brown, N.V.; Nguyen, P.; Sipos, J.A.; Chakravarti, A.; Rong, Y. Correlative study of dose to thyroid and incidence of subsequent dysfunction after head and neck radiation. Head Neck 2016, 39, 548–554. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  27. Sommat, K.; Ong, W.S.; Hussain, A.; Soong, Y.L.; Tan, T.; Wee, J.; Fong, K.W. Thyroid V40 Predicts Primary Hypothyroidism after Intensity Modulated Radiation Therapy for Nasopharyngeal Carcinoma. Int. J. Radiat. Oncol. 2017, 98, 574–580. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  28. Zhai, R.-P.; Kong, F.-F.; Du, C.-R.; Hu, C.-S.; Ying, H.-M. Radiation-induced hypothyroidism after IMRT for nasopharyngeal carcinoma: Clinical and dosimetric predictors in a prospective cohort study. Oral Oncol. 2017, 68, 44–49. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  29. Sachdev, S.; Refaat, T.; Bacchus, I.D.; Sathiaseelan, V.; Mittal, B.B. Thyroid V50 Highly Predictive of Hypothyroidism in Head-and-Neck Cancer Patients Treated with Intensity-modulated Radiotherapy (IMRT). Am. J. Clin. Oncol. 2017, 40, 413–417. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  30. Lin, Z.; Yang, Z.; He, B.; Wang, D.; Gao, X.; Tam, S.-Y.; Wu, V.W.C. Pattern of radiation-induced thyroid gland changes in nasopharyngeal carcinoma patients in 48 months after radiotherapy. PLoS ONE 2018, 13, e0200310. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  31. Xu, Y.; Shao, Z.; Tang, T.; Liu, G.; Yao, Y.; Wang, J.; Zhang, L. A dosimetric study on radiation-induced hypothyroidism following intensity-modulated radiotherapy in patients with nasopharyngeal carcinoma. Oncol. Lett. 2018, 16, 6126–6132. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  32. Lertbutsayanukul, C.; Kitpanit, S.; Prayongrat, A.; Kannarunimit, D.; Netsawang, B.; Chakkabat, C. Validation of previously reported predictors for radiation-induced hypothyroidism in nasopharyngeal cancer patients treated with intensity-modulated radiation therapy, a post hoc analysis from a Phase III randomized trial. J. Radiat. Res. 2018, 59, 446–455. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  33. El-Shebiney, M.; El-Mashad, N.; El-Mashad, W.; El-Ebiary, A.A.; Kotkat, A.E. Radiotherapeutic factors affecting the incidence of developing hypothyroidism after radiotherapy for head and neck squamous cell cancer. J. Egypt. Natl. Cancer Inst. 2018, 30, 33–38. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  34. McDowell, L.J.; Rock, K.; Xu, W.; Chan, B.; Waldron, J.; Lu, L.; Ezzat, S.; Pothier, D.; Bernstein, L.J.; So, N.; et al. Long-Term Late Toxicity, Quality of Life, and Emotional Distress in Patients with Nasopharyngeal Carcinoma Treated with Intensity Modulated Radiation Therapy. Int. J. Radiat. Oncol. 2018, 102, 340–352. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  35. Luo, R.; Wu, V.W.C.; He, B.; Gao, X.; Xu, Z.; Wang, D.; Yang, Z.; Li, M.; Lin, Z. Development of a normal tissue complication probability (NTCP) model for radiation-induced hypothyroidism in nasopharyngeal carcinoma patients. BMC Cancer 2018, 18, 575. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  36. Kamal, M.; Peeler, C.R.; Yepes, P.; Mohamed, A.S.R.; Blanchard, P.; Frank, S.; Chen, L.; Jethanandani, A.; Kuruvilla, R.; Greiner, B.; et al. Radiation-Induced Hypothyroidism after Radical Intensity Modulated Radiation Therapy for Oropharyngeal Carcinoma. Adv. Radiat. Oncol. 2020, 5, 111–119. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  37. Prpic, M.; Kruljac, I.; Kust, D.; Suton, P.; Purgar, N.; Bilos, L.K.; Gregov, M.; Mrcela, I.; Franceschi, M.; Djakovic, N.; et al. Dose-volume derived nomogram as a reliable predictor of radiotherapy-induced hypothyroidism in head and neck cancer patients. Radiol. Oncol. 2019, 53, 488–496. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  38. Huang, C.; Tan, H.; Guo, R.; Zhang, Y.; Peng, H.; Peng, L.; Lin, A.; Mao, Y.; Sun, Y.; Ma, J.; et al. Thyroid dose-volume thresholds for the risk of radiation-related hypothyroidism in nasopharyngeal carcinoma treated with intensity-modulated radiotherapy—A single-institution study. Cancer Med. 2019, 8, 6887–6893. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  39. Lin, A.J.; Zhang, J.; Cho-Lim, J.; Inouye, W.; Lee, S.P. Postradiation hypothyroidism in head and neck cancers: A Department of Veterans Affairs single-institution case-control dosimetry study. Med. Dosim. 2019, 44, 56–60. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  40. Peng, L.; Mao, Y.-P.; Huang, C.-L.; Guo, R.; Ma, J.; Wen, W.-P.; Tang, L.-L. A New Model for Predicting Hypothyroidism after Intensity-Modulated Radiotherapy for Nasopharyngeal Carcinoma. Front. Oncol. 2020, 10. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  41. Kinclová, I.; Hajtmanová, E.; Matula, P.; Balentová, S.; Muríň, P.; Ďuroška, M.; Kozlíková, K. Model-based calculation of thyroid gland normal tissue complication probability in head and neck cancer patients after radiation therapy. Strahlenther. Onkol. 2020, 196, 561–568. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  42. Zhou, L.; Chen, J.; Shen, W.; Chen, Z.-L.; Huang, S.; Tao, C.-J.; Chen, M.; Yu, Z.-H.; Chen, Y.-Y. Thyroid V50 is a risk factor for hypothyroidism in patients with nasopharyngeal carcinoma treated with intensity-modulated radiation therapy: A retrospective study. Radiat. Oncol. 2020, 15, 68. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  43. Zhu, M.-Y.; Wu, H.-J.; Miao, J.-J.; Di, M.-P.; Chen, B.-Y.; Huang, H.-G.; Mai, H.-Q.; Wang, L.; Zhao, C. Radiation-induced hypothyroidism in patients with nasopharyngeal carcinoma treated with intensity-modulated radiation therapy with or without chemotherapy: Development of a nomogram based on the equivalent dose. Oral Oncol. 2021, 120, 105378. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  44. Inoue, E.; Okajima, K.; Doi, H.; Fukuda, K.; Oguma, Y.; Ri, A.; Nishikawa, D.; Yane, K.; Matsuura, T.; Nishimura, Y. Factors predictive of the development of hypothyroidism after intensity-modulated radiation therapy for pharyngeal cancer. Acta Oto-Laryngologica 2021, 141, 1022–1026. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  45. Lu, H.-H.; Chiu, N.-T.; Tsai, M.-H. Early post-treatment 18F-FDG PET/CT for predicting radiation-induced hypothyroidism in head and neck cancer. Cancer Imaging 2022, 22, 59. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  46. Zhai, R.; Lyu, Y.; Ni, M.; Kong, F.; Du, C.; Hu, C.; Ying, H. Predictors of radiation-induced hypothyroidism in nasopharyngeal carcinoma survivors after intensity-modulated radiotherapy. Radiat. Oncol. 2022, 17, 57. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  47. Pal, S.K.; Das, S.; Isiah, R.; John, S. Determining the Occurrence of Hypothyroidism following Treatment with Radiation Therapy in Head and Neck Carcinoma Patients and the Associated Role of Risk Factors and Dose-Volume Histograms: A Prospective Study. Cureus 2022, 14, e31590. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  48. Jia-Mahasap, B.; Assavanopakun, K.; Chitapanarux, I.; Kittidachanan, K.; Sirikul, W. Incidence of radiation-induced hypothyroidism following head and neck irradiation: A single-center analysis. Rep. Pract. Oncol. Radiother. 2022, 27, 479–489. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  49. Chow, J.C.; Lui, J.C.; Cheung, K.-M.; Tam, A.H.; Lam, M.H.; Yuen, T.Y.; Lee, F.K.; Leung, A.K.; Au, K.-H.; Ng, W.-T.; et al. Post-radiation primary hypothyroidism in patients with head and neck cancer: External validation of thyroid gland dose–volume constraints with long-term endocrine outcomes. Radiother. Oncol. 2022, 177, 105–110. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  50. Harris, J.; Almarzouki, H.; Barber, B.; Scrimger, R.; Romney, J.; O’Connell, D.; Urken, M.; Seikaly, H. Free Thyroid Transfer: A Novel Procedure to Prevent Radiation-induced Hypothyroidism. Int. J. Radiat. Oncol. 2016, 96, 42–45. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  51. Harris, J.; Barber, B.; Almarzouki, H.; Scrimger, R.; Romney, J.; O’Connell, D.; Urken, M.; Seikaly, H. Free thyroid transfer: Short-term results of a novel procedure to prevent post-radiation hypothyroidism. Head Neck 2016, 39, 1234–1238. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  52. Katna, R.; Kalyani, N.; Deshpande, A. Free thyroid transfer to anterolateral thigh for prevention of radiation induced hypothyroidism: An initial experience. Am. J. Otolaryngol. 2018, 40, 160–163. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  53. Zoberi, I.; Wasserman, T.H.; Chao, K.C. A prospective, nonrandomized study of the impact of amifostine on subsequent hypothyroidism in irradiated patients with head and neck cancers. Semin. Radiat. Oncol. 2002, 12, 14–17. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  54. Alterio, D.; Jereczek-Fossa, B.A.; Franchi, B.; D’onofrio, A.; Piazzi, V.; Rondi, E.; Ciocca, M.; Gibelli, B.; Grosso, E.; Tradati, N.; et al. Thyroid disorders in patients treated with radiotherapy for head-and-neck cancer: A retrospective analysis of seventy-three patients. Int. J. Radiat. Oncol. 2007, 67, 144–150. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  55. Ishibashi, N.; Maebayashi, T.; Aizawa, T.; Sakaguchi, M.; Okada, M.; Matsushita, J. Computed Tomography Density Change in the Thyroid Gland before and after Radiation Therapy. Anticancer Res. 2018, 38, 417–421. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  56. Lin, Z.; Wu, V.W.-C.; Lin, J.; Feng, H.; Chen, L. A Longitudinal Study on the Radiation-Induced Thyroid Gland Changes after External Beam Radiotherapy of Nasopharyngeal Carcinoma. Thyroid 2011, 21, 19–23. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  57. Ulger, S.; Ulger, Z.; Yildiz, F.; Ozyar, E. Incidence of Hypothyroidism after Radiotherapy for Nasopharyngeal Carcinoma. Med. Oncol. 2007, 24, 91–94. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  58. Ranta, P.; Kytö, E.; Nissi, L.; Kinnunen, I.; Vahlberg, T.; Minn, H.; Haapio, E.; Nelimarkka, L.; Irjala, H. Dysphagia, hypothyroidism, and osteoradionecrosis after radiation therapy for head and neck cancer. Laryngoscope Investig. Otolaryngol. 2021, 7, 108–116. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  59. Wu, Y.-H.; Wang, H.-M.; Chen, H.H.-W.; Lin, C.-Y.; Chen, E.Y.-C.; Fan, K.-H.; Huang, S.-F.; Chen, I.-H.; Liao, C.-T.; Cheng, A.-J.; et al. Hypothyroidism after Radiotherapy for Nasopharyngeal Cancer Patients. Int. J. Radiat. Oncol. 2010, 76, 1133–1139. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  60. Galbo, A.M.L.; De Bree, R.; Lips, P.; Leemans, C.R. Detecting hypothyroidism after treatment for laryngeal or hypopharyngeal carcinomas: A nationwide survey in The Netherlands. Eur. Arch. Oto-Rhino-Laryngology 2008, 266, 713–718. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  61. Gormley, M.; Creaney, G.; Schache, A.; Ingarfield, K.; Conway, D.I. Reviewing the epidemiology of head and neck cancer: Definitions, trends and risk factors. Br. Dent. J. 2022, 233, 780–786. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  62. Alfouzan, A.F. Radiation therapy in head and neck cancer. Saudi Med. J. 2021, 42, 247–254. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  63. Saloura, V.; Langerman, A.; Rudra, S.; Chin, R.; Cohen, E.E. Multidisciplinary Care of the Patient with Head and Neck Cancer. Surg. Oncol. Clin. N. Am. 2013, 22, 179–215. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  64. Barton, M.B.; Jacob, S.; Shafiq, J.; Wong, K.; Thompson, S.R.; Hanna, T.P.; Delaney, G.P. Estimating the demand for radiotherapy from the evidence: A review of changes from 2003 to 2012. Radiother. Oncol. 2014, 112, 140–144. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  65. Pinnix, C.C.; Cella, L.; Andraos, T.Y.; Ayoub, Z.; Milgrom, S.A.; Gunther, J.; Thosani, S.; Wogan, C.; Conson, M.; D’Avino, V.; et al. Predictors of Hypothyroidism in Hodgkin Lymphoma Survivors after Intensity Modulated Versus 3-Dimensional Radiation Therapy. Int. J. Radiat. Oncol. 2018, 101, 530–540. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  66. Supriya, C.; Nilesh, R.; Mayuri, C.; Sadhana, K.; Reena, E.; Tapas, D.; Lavanya, G.; Prachi, M.; Amita, M.; Shylasree, T.; et al. Late toxicity within a Phase III clinical trial of IG-IMRT in cervix cancer (PARCER): Reanalysis with time weighted adverse event reporting (MOSES). Radiother. Oncol. 2022, 177, 16–20. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  67. Wortman, B.G.; Post, C.C.; Powell, M.E.; Khaw, P.; Fyles, A.; D’Amico, R.; Haie-Meder, C.; Jürgenliemk-Schulz, I.M.; McCormack, M.; Do, V.; et al. Radiation Therapy Techniques and Treatment-Related Toxicity in the PORTEC-3 Trial: Comparison of 3-Dimensional Conformal Radiation Therapy Versus Intensity-Modulated Radiation Therapy. Int. J. Radiat. Oncol. 2021, 112, 390–399. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  68. Michalski, J.M.; Yan, Y.; Watkins-Bruner, D.; Bosch, W.R.; Winter, K.; Galvin, J.M.; Bahary, J.-P.; Morton, G.C.; Parliament, M.B.; Sandler, H.M. Preliminary toxicity analysis of 3-dimensional conformal radiation therapy versus intensity modulated radiation therapy on the high-dose arm of the radiation therapy oncology group 0126 prostate cancer trial. Int. J. Radiat. Oncol. Biol. Phys. 2013, 87, 932–938. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  69. Gupta, T.; Agarwal, J.; Jain, S.; Phurailatpam, R.; Kannan, S.; Ghosh-Laskar, S.; Murthy, V.; Budrukkar, A.; Dinshaw, K.; Prabhash, K.; et al. Three-dimensional conformal radiotherapy (3D-CRT) versus intensity modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) in squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck: A randomized controlled trial. Radiother. Oncol. 2012, 104, 343–348. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  70. van Leeuwen, C.M.; Oei, A.L.; Crezee, J.; Bel, A.; Franken, N.A.P.; Stalpers, L.J.A.; Kok, H.P. The alfa and beta of tumours: A review of parameters of the linear-quadratic model, derived from clinical radiotherapy studies. Radiat. Oncol. 2018, 13, 96. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  71. Thomas, H.; Timmermann, B. Paediatric proton therapy. Br. J. Radiol. 2020, 93. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  72. Lin, S.H.; Hobbs, B.P.; Verma, V.; Tidwell, R.S.; Smith, G.L.; Lei, X.; Corsini, E.M.; Mok, I.; Wei, X.; Yao, L.; et al. Randomized Phase IIB Trial of Proton Beam Therapy Versus Intensity-Modulated Radiation Therapy for Locally Advanced Esophageal Cancer. J. Clin. Oncol. 2020, 38, 1569–1579. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  73. Yang, J.T.; Wijetunga, N.A.; Pentsova, E.; Wolden, S.; Young, R.J.; Correa, D.; Zhang, Z.; Zheng, J.; Steckler, A.; Bucwinska, W.; et al. Randomized Phase II Trial of Proton Craniospinal Irradiation Versus Photon Involved-Field Radiotherapy for Patients with Solid Tumor Leptomeningeal Metastasis. J. Clin. Oncol. 2022, 40, 3858–3867. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  74. Frank, S.J.; Blanchard, P.; Lee, J.J.; Sturgis, E.M.; Kies, M.S.; Machtay, M.; Vikram, B.; Garden, A.S.; Rosenthal, D.I.; Gunn, G.B.; et al. Comparing Intensity-Modulated Proton Therapy with Intensity-Modulated Photon Therapy for Oropharyngeal Cancer: The Journey from Clinical Trial Concept to Activation. Semin. Radiat. Oncol. 2018, 28, 108–113. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Cancers 15 04321 g001
Figure 1. Flow diagram depicting the article identification protocol. a Initial search criteria in PubMed, as of 26 November 2022: (((radiotherapy) OR (radiation therapy)) AND (head and neck)) AND ((thyroid) OR (hypothyroidism) OR (thyroid toxicity) OR (thyroid dysfunction)); b Article evaluation criteria: must be original research article describing incidence, mechanism, dosimetry, treatment, or prevention of radiation-related hypothyroidism for adults receiving RT for the treatment of head and neck cancers. c Evaluated and included non-duplicate entries from the 500 hits from the Google Scholar query “hypothyroidism after radiation therapy”.
Figure 1. Flow diagram depicting the article identification protocol. a Initial search criteria in PubMed, as of 26 November 2022: (((radiotherapy) OR (radiation therapy)) AND (head and neck)) AND ((thyroid) OR (hypothyroidism) OR (thyroid toxicity) OR (thyroid dysfunction)); b Article evaluation criteria: must be original research article describing incidence, mechanism, dosimetry, treatment, or prevention of radiation-related hypothyroidism for adults receiving RT for the treatment of head and neck cancers. c Evaluated and included non-duplicate entries from the 500 hits from the Google Scholar query “hypothyroidism after radiation therapy”.
Cancers 15 04321 g001
Cancers 15 04321 g002
Figure 2. Estimated incidence of RT-related hypothyroidism for included studies displayed over time by year of publication. Each dot represents a study, with size weighted according to the sample size of patients reported in the publication. The color of the dot reflects the method of thyroid function evaluation. Note: studies published before 2010 were excluded from this figure to improve clarity. Studies using radiographic evaluation of the thyroid gland also included biochemical evaluation and were considered as “biochemical” in the figure.
Figure 2. Estimated incidence of RT-related hypothyroidism for included studies displayed over time by year of publication. Each dot represents a study, with size weighted according to the sample size of patients reported in the publication. The color of the dot reflects the method of thyroid function evaluation. Note: studies published before 2010 were excluded from this figure to improve clarity. Studies using radiographic evaluation of the thyroid gland also included biochemical evaluation and were considered as “biochemical” in the figure.
Cancers 15 04321 g002
Cancers 15 04321 g003
Figure 3. Correlation between estimated incidence of hypothyroidism and reported mean or median follow up of selected studies. Studies using only clinical evaluation of thyroid function (n = 2) and one outlying retrospective study published in 1984 with small sample size, long follow up, and low incidence of hypothyroidism were excluded to improve clarity and accuracy of the figure.
Figure 3. Correlation between estimated incidence of hypothyroidism and reported mean or median follow up of selected studies. Studies using only clinical evaluation of thyroid function (n = 2) and one outlying retrospective study published in 1984 with small sample size, long follow up, and low incidence of hypothyroidism were excluded to improve clarity and accuracy of the figure.
Cancers 15 04321 g003
Table 1. Characteristics of included studies, with summary statistics of reported hypothyroidism incidence displayed by subgroup.
Table 1. Characteristics of included studies, with summary statistics of reported hypothyroidism incidence displayed by subgroup.
FactorCount (%)
N = 111		Estimated Hypothyroidism Incidence (%), Reported as Median (IQR)
Publication Year
2000 and prior19 (17)34 (21–43)
2001–20058 (7)44 (40–47)
2006–201015 (14)31.6 (20.8–45.3)
2011–201522 (20)33.3 (22.8–45)
2016–202032 (29)42.3 (25–46.2)
2021–202215 (14)42 (30.4–54.3)
Design
Prospective31 (28)37 (27.4–47)
Retrospective80 (72)36.1 (24–46)
Interventional
Yes4 (4)-
No97 (96)-
Mean/Median Follow Up (months)
Min6-
First Quartile21-
Median32-
Third Quartile50.2-
Max120-
Unspecified/NA24-
Sample sizeMedian 102 (62–184.75)-
Participant Type
Patients99 (98)-
Physicians2 (2)-
Cancer Site
General Head and Neck64 (58)36.7 (26–44.7)
Nasopharynx28 (25) 35 (23–46.2)
Oropharynx6 (5)57.5 (35.3–62.5)
Larynx/Hypopharynx10 (9)39.5 (28.7–48.7)
Oral Cavity3 (3)17.9 (16.1–19.7)
Radiation Therapy Modality
Photons87 (78)-
Photons/Electrons2 (2)-
Particle Therapy0 -
Unspecified22 (20)-
Radiation Therapy Technique
IMRT36 (32)42 (27.4–49.1)
Non-IMRT (2D or 3DCRT)38 (34)35 (21.8–41.6)
IMRT and 3DCRT10 (9)46.5 (27.5–50.8)
MRI-guided radiotherapy0-
Unspecified/NA27 (24)35 (23.9–48.2)
Multimodality Therapy
All therapies allowed89 (80)36.4 (24.8–45.7)
Surgery excluded13 (12)38.8 (30–47)
Surgery required4 (4)38.6 (26.2–50.5)
Unspecified/NA5 (5)36.4 (25.4–48.2)
Thyroid Evaluation
Biochemical 73 (66)38.8 (26.7–46.2)
Clinical 2 (2)4.9
Biochemical and Clinical32 (29)31.1 (23.9–49.5)
Biochemical and Radiographic2 (2)42
Unspecified/NA *2 (2)-
Abbreviations: 2D and 3DCRT; two-dimensional and three-dimensional conformal radiation therapy, IMRT; intensity-modulated radiation therapy * Refers to studies investigating physician practices regarding screening for hypothyroidism and thus were considered Unspecified/NA.
Table 2. Proposed dosimetric and organ-at-risk parameters to predict risk of RT-induced hypothyroidism.
Table 2. Proposed dosimetric and organ-at-risk parameters to predict risk of RT-induced hypothyroidism.
AuthorYearProposed Predictive Dosimetric and OAR Parameters
Boomsma, M.J. [14]2012Dmean, thyroid volume
Rønjom, M.F. [15]201325% risk of hypothyroidism for D10cc = 26 Gy, D15cc = 38 Gy, D20cc = 48 Gy, D25cc = 61 Gy
Bakhshandeh, M. [16]2013D50 < 44 Gy
Huang, S. [17]2013Dmean, V40
Murthy, V. [13]2014D100 was significant predictor on MVA
Akgun, Z. [18]2014Dmean, thyroid volume, V30
Kim, M.Y. [19]2014V45 Gy < 50%
Chyan, A. [20]2014Dmean < 49 Gy, VS 45 Gy > 3cc, VS 50 Gy > 5cc, V50 Gy < 45%
Fujiwara, M. [21]2015Dmean < 30 Gy
Rønjom, M.F. [22]2015Dmean, thyroid volume
Pil, J. [23]2016Dmean, thyroid volume
Luo, R. [24]2016V50 Gy
Lee, V. [25]2016VS 60 Gy > 10cc, VS 45 Gy > 5 cm
Ling, S. [26]2017D50 < 50 Gy, V50 < 50%, Dmean <54.58 Gy
Sommat, K. [27]2017V40 < 85%
Zhai, R. [28]2017V45 < 50%; V50 < 35%
Sachdev, S. [29]2017V50 Gy < 60%
Lin, Z. [30]2018Dmean, D50
Xu, Y. [31]2018V50 < 54.5%, Dmean < 51.6 Gy
Lertbutsayanukul, C. [32]2018VS 60 Gy > 10cc
El-Shebiney, M. [33]2018V30 < 42.1%
McDowell [34]2018V50 > 90%. V45 > 99%
Luo, R. [35]2018V50 Gy, Dmax pituitary
Kamal, M. [36]2019Dmean, thyroid volume
Prpic, M. [37]2019Dmin, thyroid volume
Huang, C. [38]2019V25 < 60%, V35 < 55%, V45 < 45%
Lin, A.J. [39]2019V50 Gy < 75%
Peng, L. [40]2020V30, V60, thyroid volume
Kinclová, I. [41]2020V40 < 85%
Zhou, L. [42]2020V50 Gy, thyroid volume < 12.82cc
Zhu, M.Y. [43]2021V35
Inoue, E. [44]2021V45 Gy > 67%
Lu, H.H. [45]2022Dmean, thyroid volume
Zhai, R. [46] 2022V40 < 80%
Pal, S.K. [47]2022D50, DmeanV50 Gy
Jia-Mahasap, B. [48]2022VS 50 Gy
Chow, J.C.H. [49]2022VS 60 Gy
Abbreviations: Vxx% refers to the percent volume of the organ receiving a specified dose. Dxx refers to the dose received by a specific volume of the gland. Dmean refers to mean dose. VSxx represents the volume of thyroid that was spared by a particular dose (thus receiving that dose or less).
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.

Share and Cite

MDPI and ACS Style

Rooney, M.K.; Andring, L.M.; Corrigan, K.L.; Bernard, V.; Williamson, T.D.; Fuller, C.D.; Garden, A.S.; Gunn, B.; Lee, A.; Moreno, A.C.; et al. Hypothyroidism following Radiotherapy for Head and Neck Cancer: A Systematic Review of the Literature and Opportunities to Improve the Therapeutic Ratio. Cancers 2023, 15, 4321. https://doi.org/10.3390/cancers15174321

AMA Style

Rooney MK, Andring LM, Corrigan KL, Bernard V, Williamson TD, Fuller CD, Garden AS, Gunn B, Lee A, Moreno AC, et al. Hypothyroidism following Radiotherapy for Head and Neck Cancer: A Systematic Review of the Literature and Opportunities to Improve the Therapeutic Ratio. Cancers. 2023; 15(17):4321. https://doi.org/10.3390/cancers15174321

Chicago/Turabian Style

Rooney, Michael K., Lauren M. Andring, Kelsey L. Corrigan, Vincent Bernard, Tyler D. Williamson, Clifton D. Fuller, Adam S. Garden, Brandon Gunn, Anna Lee, Amy C. Moreno, and et al. 2023. "Hypothyroidism following Radiotherapy for Head and Neck Cancer: A Systematic Review of the Literature and Opportunities to Improve the Therapeutic Ratio" Cancers 15, no. 17: 4321. https://doi.org/10.3390/cancers15174321

Note that from the first issue of 2016, this journal uses article numbers instead of page numbers. See further details here.

Article Metrics

Back to TopTop